The New York Yankees are entering the 2025 MLB season under a cloud of uncertainty, grappling with significant injuries to pivotal players just weeks before Opening Day. Chief among their concerns is the absence of ace pitcher Gerrit Cole, who will miss the entire season after undergoing Tommy John surgery. Cole, a former Cy Young award winner, was expected to anchor the rotation, making his removal a heavy blow to the team’s aspirations.
In addition to Cole's absence, Luis Gil is anticipated to be sidelined until at least the end of May as he recovers from a lat strain. The situation worsens with Clarke Schmidt showing signs of shoulder fatigue, raising concerns about his readiness to start the season. Schmidt's limited participation during spring training—only one start and a modest bullpen appearance—could very well result in his placement on the injured list.
This unfortunate string of injuries has forced the Yankees to think on their feet. If Schmidt is indeed placed on the injured list, the organization is likely to promote both Carlos Carrasco and Will Warren to the Opening Day roster. Considering their impressive performances during spring training, both pitchers could play critical roles in stabilizing a rotation that has become one of the weakest in the league.
While the loss of key pitchers puts a damper on the Yankees’ chances to compete effectively, the team maintains a positive outlook. Aaron Judge, the Yankees' captain and a driving force on the field, remains undeterred by these setbacks. "Nobody in this room is fazed, which I think has been incredible... You miss Gerrit Cole, one of the best pitchers in the game, and Luis Gil, who emerged as probably our second-best starter last season... But I think we’ve got some young guys I feel are going to step up," Judge stated, showing a commitment to rallying the team.
Among the young players the Yankees are pinning hopes on are Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe, Austin Wells, Ben Rice, and Will Warren. Each represents the kind of talent Judge believes might rise to the occasion in a critical time. It’s a hopeful perspective amidst the growing anxiety surrounding the team's pitching staff.
As fans eagerly anticipate the season, there’s been speculation about a possible trade to enhance the pitching roster. Alexander Wilson of Empire Sports Media has reported on a potential trade involving Sandy Alcantara from the Miami Marlins. The former Cy Young winner is currently working his way back from Tommy John surgery, and while he didn't pitch in 2024, he has looked sharp this spring. "Alcantara, on the other hand, presents a different kind of opportunity... The Marlins would require a significant return given his team-friendly contract," Wilson wrote, suggesting that acquiring Alcantara could fill the gaping hole left by Cole.
Compounding these challenges is a significant cultural shift within the Yankees organization. For the first time in half a century, players are now allowed to grow beards, breaking a tradition that has been in place since 1976. This change, confirmed by owner Hal Steinbrenner, reflects a modernizing approach aimed at attracting prospective players. Judge admitted that while he has followed the rule since being drafted in 2013, he supports lifting the restriction if it helps the team. "If it gets us a couple more players that’ll help us win games, everybody will be on board for that," he affirmed.
As the Yankees navigate these turbulent waters, the hope is that a blend of experienced players and emerging talent can come together to deliver results. The stakes are high—it's been sixteen long years since the Yankees last hoisted a championship trophy, and the pressure to succeed is palpable. At this early juncture, the focus remains on overcoming the adversities presented by injuries and making the necessary adjustments in their strategic approach.
Ultimately, while the current challenges are daunting, the Yankees are not shying away from their goal of bringing home a championship. The path may be fraught with obstacles, but whether it’s adapting to injuries or embracing new traditions, the overarching narrative remains clear. The Bronx Bombers are poised to give it everything they've got, with or without their star players; winning—a championship—is the goal they’re committed to achieving.
