René Casselly and Kathrin Menzinger shined brightly at the "Let’s Dance Christmas Show 2024," held on December 20. The pair, known for their incredible skills on the dance floor, secured the coveted title of "Christmas Dancing Star" after receiving the most votes from viewers. This festive special not only showcased stunning performances but also set the stage for emotional viewer reactions, as the audience reflected on changing dynamics from past shows.
Last week’s holiday edition brought together beloved stars from previous seasons, who showcased various dance styles including the classic waltz and energetic jive. Casselly, who already has the honor of winning the 15th season of "Let’s Dance," felt the weight of expectations as he returned to the spotlight with Menzinger. Their performances, especially their jive and contemporary dance, captivated the jury, earning them high praise.
Renowned judge Motsi Mabuse expressed delight, insinuated she would prefer to see their talents highlighted on broader, perhaps even international, platforms like Las Vegas. “Motsi Mabuse wants René and Kathrin not just on the 'Let’s Dance' floor, but rather showcasing their talents on stages as grand as those found in Las Vegas,” said RTL. Their closing act, where they synchronized beautifully mid-air, was described as legendary, creating awe among both the audience and judges.
Despite the joyful celebrations, the show faced challenges this year, particularly concerning viewership numbers. With 2.25 million viewers tuning in, the ratings indicated a drop compared to previous years, where figures hovered close to 2.69 million. Post-show data revealed RTL’s market share resting at 10.8 percent, but the audience comprised less younger viewers than ever before. The decline culminated as news broadcasts attracted more timely attention, such as coverage about unsettling events related to community tragedies.
It didn’t stop there—the pre-recorded nature of the show raised eyebrows as questions unfolded on social media about the legitimacy of audience voting. Participants could see how the show was recorded months prior, yet voting remained open as if it were live. Queries flooded social networks, with fans asking, “Can someone explain how voting works when it’s not live?” This sparked discussions about authenticity and engagement, shifting the viewer experience from participatory to passive, igniting critiques about how genuine the finale felt to the audience.
Among the cast, the return of former contestant Amira Aly drew attention too. Despite receiving favorable comments from the jury, Amira navigated the spotlight amid playful barbs from host Daniel Hartwich. “Dear Amira, say hi to your ex-partner!” Hartwich jested just before her dance, referencing Massimo Sinató, who she danced with previously. Amira accepted the teasing with good humor, responding, "Two and a half years—much can happen, and HAS happened!”
This year’s event symbolized not just dance but also the intertwined personal stories of its participants, peppered with public narratives of love, separation, and camaraderie. Social media buzz highlighted mixed feelings surrounding the pre-recorded format, including nostalgia for spontaneous, live competitions versus the modern trend of planned performances.
Donning red during the finale added to the event's seasonal joy, giving viewers comfort and cheer amid changes. René Casselly’s second title places him among the elite within the "Let’s Dance" franchise. Even with the dwindling viewership numbers compared to the past, the panel of judges and the fans remain optimistic about future installments of the franchise, particularly as insights tease the kick-off of the next regular show slated for 2025.
With one candidate already hinted to be stepping onto the dance floor next year, anticipation begins to build. Despite challenges this year, both the competitors’ display of talent and the emotional weight of their stories capture the vibrant spirit of dance and connection—a reminder of why audiences tune in, year after year.
Going forward, one wonders how this festive spirit will translate as the show returns to its regular format next season. Will the stars align for renewed excitement, or will viewers find themselves yearning for the festive cheer of special editions during holiday seasons? Only time, and the dance floor, hold the answer.
