Episode 6 of the Hulu series Good American Family, titled "Not Today Satan," was released for streaming on April 16, 2025, at 12 am PT and 3 am ET. The show, which began airing on March 19, 2025, with a two-episode premiere, has captivated audiences with its compelling narrative based on the true story of Natalia Grace Barnett, a Ukrainian orphan whose adoption by American couple Kristine and Michael Barnett sparked controversy and legal battles.
Starring Ellen Pompeo as Kristine Barnett and Mark Duplass as Michael Barnett, the series dives deep into the complexities of their relationship with Natalia, portrayed by Imogen Faith Reid. The show explores themes of trust, abandonment, and the ambiguity of truth, as it presents the story from multiple perspectives. Episode 6 continues this narrative by introducing a new character, Cynthia Mans, played by Christina Hendricks, who helps Natalia navigate her tumultuous situation.
The episode begins with Natalia struggling in a GED class, a requirement imposed by Kristine to ensure her financial independence. However, the assignment proves challenging as it forces Natalia to confront her past and the traumatic experiences she has endured. In a moment of desperation, she encounters Cynthia Mans, who offers her assistance. Hendricks describes her character as someone who provides a "place of comfort, protection, nurturing and a safe space" for Natalia, complicating the viewer's perception of her intentions.
As the episode unfolds, viewers witness the delicate balance of trust and skepticism that Natalia experiences with Cynthia. While Cynthia initially appears to be a savior for the troubled child, her actions raise questions about her motivations. For instance, during a grocery shopping trip, Cynthia suggests using Natalia's EBT card to pay for her family’s groceries, adding a layer of complexity to her character. Hendricks acknowledges the intricacies of playing Cynthia, stating, "I think it was really important to have those little moments because [I] come in at a time where we’re flipping perspectives, so it really needed to be a huge juxtaposition to what you were seeing from the Barnetts’ side."
In a shocking twist, the episode reveals that the Barnetts had legally changed Natalia's birth certificate to reflect a birth year of 1989, despite her Ukrainian adoption paperwork stating she was born in 2003. This alteration played a significant role in the legal battles that ensued, as the Barnetts claimed that Natalia was an adult masquerading as a child. The Barnetts adopted her in 2010, believing she was six years old, but later alleged that she threatened them and attempted to harm their family.
The series has garnered attention not only for its dramatic storytelling but also for its handling of sensitive subjects, such as adoption and child welfare. Liz Garbus, a two-time Oscar nominee and Emmy winner, directed the first and fifth episodes, bringing her documentary expertise to the scripted format. Garbus emphasizes the importance of perspective in storytelling, noting, "What Katie Robbins has done with Good American Family is tell a story that can be interpreted so differently depending on where you’re sitting and who you’re listening to."
As the narrative progresses, Cynthia’s role becomes increasingly significant. She acts as a protector for Natalia, demanding real help from a doctor and even referring to herself as Natalia’s mother. By the end of Episode 6, Natalia is seen clean, fed, and smiling, a stark contrast to her previous living conditions. This transformation raises further questions about the nature of care and the complexities of relationships formed under such distressing circumstances.
Hendricks reflects on the challenges of portraying such a multifaceted character, stating, "This is not a black-and-white story by any means, and we have to show those moments of question and of Natalia’s questioning." Her portrayal of Cynthia aims to balance warmth and protectiveness with the inherent complexities of her character's intentions.
Moreover, the series has sparked discussions about the real-life implications of the Barnetts' actions and the subsequent legal proceedings. In 2019, Kristine and Michael Barnett faced multiple charges of neglecting a dependent, though Michael was acquitted, and the case against Kristine was dismissed. The Manses, who later became guardians of Natalia, filed a court petition in 2016 to seek legal guardianship, further complicating the narrative.
As the show continues to air weekly episodes, with Episode 7 set to release on April 23, 2025, audiences are left to ponder the moral dilemmas presented in the story. The series invites viewers to question the reliability of the characters' narratives and to consider the broader implications of adoption and familial relationships.
In addition to its engaging plot, Good American Family also highlights the importance of representation in media. With a diverse cast and complex characters, the show aims to reflect the realities faced by many families navigating similar challenges. As the series progresses, it promises to delve deeper into the intricacies of trust, love, and the search for identity, making it a thought-provoking addition to Hulu's lineup.
For those eager to catch up on the series, Good American Family is available for streaming on Hulu in the United States and on Disney+ for international viewers, with release dates varying by region. The show is produced by Calamity Jane and 20th Television, both part of the Walt Disney Company, ensuring a high production value that complements its compelling storytelling.
As the story of Natalia Grace continues to unfold, viewers are left with lingering questions about the nature of family, the complexities of trust, and the impact of trauma on young lives. With each episode, Good American Family challenges audiences to reflect on these themes, making it a must-watch for fans of gripping drama.
