Jack Fincham, the 32-year-old winner of the 2018 series of Love Island, has been sentenced to six weeks in prison after his Cane Corso dog, Elvis, bit a runner during two separate incidents. The sentencing took place at Southend Magistrates’ Court on January 29, 2025, where Fincham pleaded guilty to two counts of being charged with dangerously out of control dogs. His partner, television personality Chloe Brockett, was visibly upset during the proceedings.
The dog attack occurred on September 2022 when the dog bit runner Robert Sudell, which was followed by another incident involving the same dog in Grays, Essex, where no injuries were reported, but it was still deemed dangerous. According to prosecutor Erin Peck, during sentencing, the presiding magistrate, Anne Wade, remarked on the seriousness of the incidents, highlighting how Fincham had failed to abide by previously imposed conditions, which included keeping Elvis muzzled and on a lead.
Fincham, who gained notoriety on Love Island alongside Dani Dyer, accepted full responsibility for his dog’s behavior. He appeared to acknowledge the impact of his actions, as the magistrate expressed concern, stating, "The dog was in a public place not abiding by the conditions to be muzzled and kept on a lead." This was compounded by the fact Fincham was already subject to a suspended sentence for unrelated driving offences, leading to enforcement of part of this sentence.
Following his sentencing, Fincham faces hefty penalties totaling £3580, which includes £200 compensation for Sudell and £50 for another victim of his dog. Magistrate Wade set up a payment plan, permitting him to pay £400 monthly upon his release, citing Fincham’s lack of savings as reported by his lawyer Richard Cooper.
This legal ruling has sparked discussions about Fincham’s dog ownership history, particularly the controversies surrounding Elvis, who he imported from Russia. The dog reportedly had cropped ears, which, as noted by animal rights group PETA, is illegal within the UK. The situation highlights the concerns tied to owning large, powerful breeds amid rising instances of dangerous dog behavior.
Fincham initially shared about his bond with Elvis on social media, stating, "My best friend in the whole world. Have a story to tell you very soon. Sometimes I think this country is done honestly," implying the challenges he faces. Interestingly, this bond did not prevent another altercation in June 2024, pointing to broader concerns about dog ownership and responsibility.
The RSPCA has expressed serious concern over the trends of so-called "status dogs" being linked to antisocial behaviour. Dr. Samantha Gaines emphasized, "We've seen trends in different pets being used for antisocial behaviour and as, so-called, 'status dogs'…" reinforcing the necessity of responsible ownership.
Following his release, Fincham must adhere to strict conditions for Elvis, including keeping the dog on a lead, muzzled, and not allowing him to be left alone with anyone under 16. There is skepticism and speculation about what this means for his public image and his future as a dog owner.
This case serves as a noteworthy reminder of the responsibilities tied to pet ownership, particularly for potentially dangerous breeds, and the legal repercussions stemming from failure to uphold these standards. The community remains watchful and concerned for both the safety of the public and the well-being of such animals.