The New York Giants have made significant moves in their quarterback lineup, signing both Jameis Winston and Russell Wilson in a bid to rejuvenate their offense ahead of the 2025 NFL season.
On March 25, 2025, the Giants announced the signing of Winston to a contract worth two years at $8 million, alongside Wilson, who signed a one-year deal that could be worth up to $21 million with incentives. This aggressive strategy comes on the heels of a disappointing 2024 season, where the Giants finished last in the NFC East.
Aaron Rodgers, the star quarterback who remains on the market, has also garnered attention in connection to the Giants, leading to speculation about his potential role. With the NFL Draft looming, set to commence on April 24, general manager Joe Schoen seems determined to provide multiple options as the team seeks a franchise quarterback to lead them into the future.
Winston's contract averages out to $4 million a year, mirroring what he earned in recent seasons with the New Orleans Saints and Cleveland Browns. Observers note that this figure represents a backup's salary rather than that of a starter. It underscores the Giants' strategy: to keep options open without committing solely to Winston as their primary quarterback.
The potential for competition remains, as some analysts predict Winston might start an average of 5.5 games, depending on how the roster unfolds and if the Giants choose to draft a rookie quarterback like Shedeur Sanders or Cam Ward with their third overall pick. Meanwhile, Wilson, who turned 37 in November 2025, aims to prove he still has what it takes after finishing with a record of 6-5 and throwing for 2,482 yards last season.
An insider claimed, "Jameis will provide a strong presence in the Giants' locker room, but it's essential to recognize that he brings with him a certain level of unpredictability—he's chaos, to some degree" as the team reinvents its dynamic. This insight frames Winston not just as a stopgap but as a player who can bring pizzazz, albeit with caution.
Wilson’s history also speaks volumes, having had past performances that included a 63.7% completion rate and 16 touchdown passes during his time with the Steelers. However, his consistent performance was questioned after his playoff exit against the Baltimore Ravens, emphasizing that while he has talent, the emphasis will be on whether he can stabilize the Giants' offense this season.
The focus now shifts to the Giants' draft strategy. With the third pick in the upcoming draft, the team remains in discussions about possibly trading up to land a top rookie. Their recent signings indicate a multifaceted plan: if they do select a young quarterback, having both Wilson and Winston allows for a layer of insurance, should those rookies need time to acclimate.
Previously, the Giants struggled with Daniel Jones, who was viewed as a significant misfire by the franchise over the last few years. Moving on from that past, the organization's latest choices are aimed at finding stability. Analysts point out that the drafting of a promising rookie quarterback coupled with veterans like Winston and Wilson may uniquely position the Giants to bounce back.
Tommy DeVito, a young add-on for depth, has also signed a one-year contract worth $1 million. He, too, is expected to participate in training alongside Winston and Wilson. The Giants’ investment in veteran quarterbacks is likely an attempt to shield whichever rookie they select until he is ready to take the reins.
This offseason's strategic moves reflect a broader willingness from Schoen to explore every avenue to secure the right quarterback for the Giants. The current lineup is designed to give the team maximum flexibility, allowing for future adjustments while observing how the draft and future games unfold.
As the NFL Draft approaches, the Giants' front office seems undeterred by previous failures, preparing to tackle the offseason with a fresh perspective. Ultimately, the combination of Wilson and Winston will not only bring competitive spirit but also valuable mentorship for any incoming rookies. As former players have successfully transitioned into coaching roles, securing both quarterbacks signifies a calculated risk as Schoen navigates the delicate balance of readying a team for the upcoming season while keeping potential talents in sight.
Through careful maneuvering, the Giants potentially position themselves to improve not just for the 2025 season, but for years to come in their quest to regain a playoff spot and solidify their standing in the NFC.
