El Salvador's Legislative Assembly made headlines on Monday by voting to overturn the country’s historic 2017 ban on metal mining, gratifying President Nayib Bukele, who has long advocated for this legislative shift. Dubbed by some as 'the world’s coolest dictator', Bukele’s government aims to capitalize on the country's mineral wealth, claiming the gold reserves could be worth approximately $3 trillion.
The ban repeal, which was initiated by Bukele's Nueva Ideas party, saw overwhelming support within the assembly, with 57 votes favoring the change and only 3 opposing it. Under the new law, mining will be permitted throughout the country except within nature reserves and sensitive watersheds. This decisive action follows Bukele’s pledges to rejuvenate the nation's economy by tapping its natural resources.
Although the government claims this mining initiative could transform the country’s economic prospects, many critics express deep concern, particularly about potential environmental destruction. The 2017 ban was the first of its kind globally, primarily rooted in widespread public apprehension over the detrimental impacts of metal mining, including the use of toxic chemicals such as cyanide and mercury.
Environmental advocates and organizations have been quick to voice their opposition to the repeal. For example, the Institute for Policy Studies warned earlier this month of the potential catastrophic effects on El Salvador's water supply, observing, "Overturning [the ban] would be a death sentence for the small and densely populated country with its scarce water sources, many of which are already contaminated.”
Former Archbishop of San Salvador, Msgr. José Luis Escobar Alas, also proclaimed, “It will damage this country forever,” during one of his homilies against the mining revival. This sentiment was shared by numerous civic and environmental activists who expressed outrage at the assembly's decision and rallied outside government buildings, with environmentalist Luis Gonzalez stating, “We oppose metals mining because it has been technically and scientifically proven…”.
The strong coalition of critics includes church leaders, civic organizations, scholars, and concerned citizens, all voicing their apprehensions about the long-term ramifications of such mining endeavors. Conversely, Bukele has consistently framed the mining issue as one of economic opportunity. He is optimistic about potential gold and silver deposits within the country, advocating the belief these resources could uplift the nation's financial future.
Previous exploratory projects, prior to the ban, suggested El Salvador’s gold belt holds significant wealth; the El Dorado project, one of the most advanced, once indicated reserves of about 1.4 million ounces of gold, valued at approximately $3.6 billion. Yet, experts have remained skeptical of the broader claims about untapped resources, noting the potential environmental degradation as more miners look to exploit these natural assets.
After the mining ban was unanimously instituted following over ten years of grassroots campaigning, its genesis was deeply rooted in the fight for environmental preservation. This campaign led to the banning of mining due to evidence linking industrial practices to severe ecological damage, especially water contamination incidents associated with practices involving heavy metals.
Despite the fervent protests against the repeal, Bukele has remained undeterred. He decried the prior restrictions as “absurd,” marking the shift as necessary for national progress and development. Amidst the clamor of his supporters who share his vision of economic rejuvenation through mining, Bukele continues to assert the invaluable economic potential buried beneath Salvadoran soil.
The widespread opposition may complicate the administration's efforts moving forward as the realities of mining endeavors often clash with public sentiment prioritizing environmental and public health over economic opportunities. Recent polls echo this sentiment, indicating the majority of Salvadorans remain cautious about mining, reflecting concerns about the preservation of their lands and resources.
With this law expected to soon go live pending Bukele’s approval, the coming months will be pivotal. The Salvadoran government faces the challenge of addressing both the potential economic benefits of mining and the significant backlash from environmentalists and residents who fear their communities will bear the brunt of environmental degradation.
.