Death in Paradise has ushered in a new era with the debut of Don Gilet as the show’s latest lead detective, Detective Inspector Mervin Wilson. Airing during the Christmas special, this episode not only introduces Gilet but also serves as the first festive offering since Ralf Little's exit as DI Neville Parker, who had become a beloved character over his multi-season tenure.
Gilet's character, DI Mervin Wilson, was initially seen boarding a flight to London when he received the unexpected call from Commissioner Selwyn Patterson, played by Don Warrington, demanding his assistance with a perplexing murder case on the fictional Caribbean island of Saint Marie. This strange case involved three men dressed as Santa Claus who were found dead under suspicious circumstances. Reluctantly cutting his vacation short, Mervin made his way back to solve the case, marking his entry as the series' fifth inspector.
Viewers were quick to react to Mervin's performance on social media, with reactions ranging from skepticism to praise. Some fans took to X (formerly Twitter) to express their mixed feelings about the new character. One user tweeted, "Bring back Neville! Not sure I like this new DI!" Another mentioned the new character's attitude, stating, "Mervin's a bit rude, especially to the ladies!" Not all feedback was negative, with others chiming in positively, saying, "Loved Don Gilet in the show!"
Critics have also weighed in on Gilet's debut. Ed Power, writing for The Independent, remarked, "His phlegmatic, crotchety persona harks back to the OG Death in Paradise policeman abroad, Richard Poole." While praising Gilet's performance, Power noted the episode’s convoluted murder plot detracted from the engagement. It’s evident Gilet's portrayal brings something unique to the long-running series.
Gilet himself discussed the challenges of stepping onto the show’s hallowed stage, admitting to nerves about replacing a well-loved character. During his interview, he remarked, "Being offered the new lead role in Death in Paradise feels like a deeply loved and incredibly precious jewel has been placed in my hands." Gilet described Mervin as blunt, opinionated, and emotionally closed off, pointing out the ways his character may rub colleagues the wrong way as he attempts to establish his footing.
This departure from the traditionally bumbling and warm demeanor of previous inspectors introduces fresh dynamics within the show. Gilet's portrayal captures Mervin’s urgent, fast-paced approach to police work, contrasting sharply with the island's laid-back operations. Throughout the episode, Mervin’s interactions with his new colleagues left audiences entertained, intrigued, and occasionally exasperated.
Without the usual miscommunications, audiences can expect engaging growth for both Gilet’s character and the existing ensemble as they navigate their professional relationships within the picturesque backdrop of Saint Marie. This shift also allows for narrative exploration of how Mervin, with his quick wit and brusque nature, will collaborate with the team.
Fans eagerly anticipating season 14, set to premiere sometime next year, find solace as their favorite series now features this bold character shift. Indeed, adaptations within long-running shows like Death in Paradise are pivotal, and with Gilet's entry, there are high hopes for character development and storytelling depth.
Don Gilet’s introduction enjoyed success during its initial episode, leading to speculation about what’s next for the show. Though the Christmas special had mixed reviews overall, the anticipation of new narratives—and his character’s interaction within the existing cast—has fans and critics alike curious about the direction Death in Paradise will take as it heads toward its next season.
