The New York Yankees are facing potential challenges as star slugger Giancarlo Stanton returned to New York from spring training on February 19, 2025. Though initial reports by manager Aaron Boone indicated his absence was due to personal matters, concerns about Stanton’s elbow injuries—ongoing issues since last season—remain prominent as the team gears up for the 2025 season.
Manager Aaron Boone addressed the media from Fort Myers, where the Yankees were set to go against the Boston Red Sox. He offered limited details about Stanton’s situation, stating, “I can tell you he is in New York, but it’s personal in nature, and I’m going to leave it atthat for now.” Stanton’s return to New York has raised alarms about his readiness for the opening game against the Milwaukee Brewers, scheduled for March 27.
Stanton, who has been dealing with tennis elbow issues affecting both arms, has had very little active participation this spring, reportedly engaging only in light agility drills since his arrival at camp. His absence from swinging the bat for several weeks has led to heightened speculation about the condition of his elbows, and the team is cautious not to push him too soon.
Aaron Judge, the team captain, expressed optimism about Stanton’s mindset saying, “He’s one of the strongest physically I’ve seen and also mentally. Just to be able to handle the ups and downs of playing in New York and then battling some injuries he’s had throughout the season. It’s just a little bump in the road. Rather have this now than the middle of the season.”
With Opening Day less than six weeks away, the Yankees are running out of time to get Stanton back to full strength. The team will take every precaution necessary to monitor his health, holding out hope for his eventual return. Boone has indicated nothing has changed with Stanton’s elbow status, noting, “I’m expecting him to be okay. It’s just a matter of when we want to start really rolling it out to give us the best chance to get as much of him as we can.”
Reports from multiple media sources indicated Stanton returned to New York for medical evaluations and consultation with Dr. Christopher Ahmad, the Yankees’ head physician. According to NJ Advance Media, Stanton’s examination will likely include tests associated with his persistent elbow pain. The article also emphasized, “Surgery would be the last line of defense but has so far not been seriously considered.” The team’s cautious approach aims to avoid the recurrence of past injuries, especially following Stanton’s commendable postseason performance, where he earned ALCS MVP honors.
Stanton’s previous success came as he played through discomfort, hitting seven home runs during the postseason, showcasing his resilience and power as one of the Yankees' star hitters. Yet, the continued uncertainty surrounding his health adds pressure before the start of the new season, as the Yankees aim to replicate last year’s success.
Alongside Stanton's health woes, the Yankees are also considering potential adjustments to their lineup. Players like Oswaldo Cabrera, DJ LeMahieu, and Alex Verdugo might take on larger roles should Stanton be unable to participate. The loss of Stanton, especially as he fills the designated hitter role, would require modifications to the batting order leading up to the season opener.
Although Boone and his team remain hopeful about Stanton’s eventual return, they are not shying away from contingency plans to strengthen the squad. It’s evident they are aware of the pressures to secure offensive power, especially with the recent shift of Juan Soto to the Mets, leaving a noticeable gap within the lineup.
Aaron Boone stated, “Hopefully soon,” referring to Stanton’s timeline for returning to training. Yet, questions linger on when he will be able to start increasing his activities and contribute as needed for the Yankees.
Giancarlo Stanton’s ability to hit at full capacity is imperative for the Yankees' hopes this season. The team understands the importance of targeting the best path forward for Stanton, aiming to balance health management with readiness to compete as they prepare for what lies ahead.
With the uncertainty about Stanton's health and the lead-up to Opening Day, all eyes will be on the Yankees to see how they navigate the situation. The decision-making process will require careful consideration of Stanton’s long-term well-being against the goal of starting the season strong.