CBS's latest medical drama, Watson, premiered on January 27, 2025, and has stirred conversation for its unique blend of Sherlock Holmes legacy and hospital intrigue. Centering on Morris Chestnut's character, John Watson, the show picks up six months after Sherlock Holmes' untimely demise, propelling viewers deep within the medical mysteries of Pittsburgh.
Launching the series immediately following the AFC Championship Game seems strategic for CBS, aiming to capture the attention of sports fans and new viewers alike. The pilot episode features John Watson grappling with the emotional turmoil of Holmes' death, which he witnessed firsthand during the climax at Reichenbach Falls. This dramatic backdrop sets the tone for Watson's recovery and eventual return to medical practice at the newly established Holmes Clinic.
The series, created by Craig Sweeny, strays quite intentionally from the classic detective formula. Instead of engaging audiences solely through crime-solving, Watson introduces perplexing medical cases—each episode structured around Watson and his clinic staff tackling rare illnesses. This shift promises to keep the storytelling fresh, as the procedural format places the spotlight on medical enigmas rather than traditional criminal investigations.
The series builds its emotional framework around the character dynamics, particularly with Shinwell Johnson, who assists Watson as he navigates both his grief and the establishment of the clinic. Ritchie Coster as Shinwell introduces layers of friendship and support but, as some critics noted, the groundwork for more complex relationships may need clarification to resonate with viewers.
Alongside Shinwell, the clinic's staff includes various new characters who contribute to the medical dilemma of the week. Their introductions are pivotal; for example, Ingrid Dean, played by Eve Harlow, supports Watson not only as staff but also from her perspective as his treating physician. Yet, as reviews have pointed out, there’s often confusion with character backstories and motivations, leaving viewers wanting more cohesion among the ensemble cast.
One of the most anticipated appearances was Randall Park as the notorious villain Moriarty, whose surprise casting was unveiled at the episode’s conclusion. This choice—a far cry from the conventional serious portrayal of Moriarty—invited mixed feedback. “I’m known for playing amiable, nice guys. So it was a surprise to get the call. A welcome surprise. The idea of playing a villain is thrilling to me,” Park remarked to USA Today, creating intrigue among viewers eager to see this new take on the character.
Sweeny explained the rationale behind casting Park—“I’m always thinking about what’s the most fun for the audience.” The unexpected layering of comedic charm over the sinister attributes of Moriarty has sparked discussions online, with viewers expressing their excitement over this new approach. Comments such as “RANDALL PARK AS MORIARTY?! YOOOOOO!!! THIS IS EPIC!” highlight how this shift not only adds depth but transforms expectations within the usual Holmes narrative.
Another draw is the series' unique location—shifting from the foggy settings of London to the vibrant landscapes of Pittsburgh. Yet, as some locals noted, certain regional references felt forced, raising questions about authenticity. The show, filmed primarily outside of this metropolis, sometimes struggles to find grounding within the very city it claims as its home base. Critique of the show positions Pittsburgh more as backdrop than character, though establishing shots provide viewers with glimpses of its renowned skyline.
Despite these critiques, the procedural charm of Watson holds personal draw for many, catering to audiences seeking engaging yet relaxed viewing experiences. Critics collectively recognized Morris Chestnut's charisma as the shining star—his proven charm grabs viewers’ attention even when other script elements fall flat. “Watson works for the most part, but it feels like it could be sexier,” remarked one reviewer, touching on the allure of potential narrative expansion.
While the pilot is by no means flawless, the combination of familiar and new elements—melding medical cases, the legacy of Sherlock Holmes, and unexpected character portrayals—sets the stage for future episodes to refine the formula. Whether Watson can evolve beyond its initial tepid reception and chemistry issues remains to be seen, but the tension between Watson and Moriarty as the season progresses promises to keep viewers engaged.
The show will return for its regular Sunday night slot on February 16, 2025, providing more opportunities to explore these medical conundrums and character dynamics. It’s now up to the audience and CBS to determine if the innovative twist on this well-trodden universe holds lasting appeal.