Amy Sherman-Palladino and Dan Palladino, the Emmy-winning creators behind beloved series like Gilmore Girls and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, are diving into the competitive world of ballet with their new show, Étoile. This eight-episode dramedy, available for streaming on Prime Video, explores the lives of dancers and executives at two renowned ballet companies in New York City and Paris as they attempt a risky talent exchange to revive their struggling institutions.
The premise of Étoile revolves around the Metropolitan Ballet Theatre in New York and Le Ballet National in Paris, both facing declining ticket sales in the aftermath of the pandemic. To attract audiences, the two companies' directors, Jack McMillan (played by Luke Kirby) and Geneviève Lavigne (Charlotte Gainsbourg), agree to swap their top performers. This unconventional marketing strategy is backed by billionaire Crispin Shamblee (Simon Callow), whose dubious funding raises ethical questions for Jack, a former lover of Geneviève.
At the center of the drama is Cheyenne Toussaint (Lou de Laâge), a fiery and talented dancer from Paris who is sent to New York, and Tobias Bell (Gideon Glick), a choreographer with a unique vision who must adapt to the different artistic environment in France. Cheyenne’s character is compelling; she embodies the struggles of a dancer who feels that her identity is inseparable from her art. In a poignant moment, she tells Jack, “No, but it is who I am so there is no choice,” highlighting her internal conflict.
Tom Ward, who served as a co-executive producer and writer for Étoile, described his journey working with the Palladinos as a “crazy, crazy journey.” After being approached by the duo in late 2022, Ward relocated his family from rural New Zealand to Brooklyn to take part in the production. He expressed admiration for the Palladinos' ability to blend humor and drama, drawing parallels to his previous work on Please Like Me.
“When they look at the world, they see the theatrics of life that can exist around everyday drama,” Ward said, emphasizing the show’s exploration of the dance world’s complexities and the personal lives of its characters. The series captures the chaotic yet passionate environment of ballet, showcasing the rigorous dedication required to succeed.
While Étoile is set against the backdrop of elite ballet, it is ultimately about the people within that world. The ensemble cast, which includes characters like Mishi Duplessis (Taïs Vinolo), a young dancer navigating her own path, and Gabin Roux (Ivan du Pontavice), an ambitious performer, adds depth to the narrative. Each character grapples with their ambitions and the pressures of the dance industry, creating a rich tapestry of stories that resonate with audiences.
The dialogue in Étoile is characteristically fast-paced and filled with the witty, sharp exchanges that fans of Sherman-Palladino have come to love. While the show may not reach the frenetic energy of Gilmore Girls, it maintains a unique rhythm that captivates viewers. A standout moment occurs in a scene where Cheyenne and her mother walk through a Parisian cemetery, engaging in a dialogue that showcases both the warmth and spikiness typical of the Palladino style.
Critics have noted the show's ability to balance humor with serious themes, such as the precarious nature of the arts. Charlotte Gainsbourg, who portrays Geneviève, emphasized the importance of addressing the fragility of the arts in today's society. "I hope it speaks to the importance of the arts and the fact that they're under siege right now," she said. This sentiment resonates throughout the series, prompting viewers to reflect on the value of artistic expression.
Despite the show's many strengths, some critics have pointed out that it occasionally struggles with tonal consistency. The ambitious narrative, which includes elements of comedy, drama, and satire, can feel disjointed at times. However, the performances of the cast, particularly the lead dancers, help ground the story. The series features real-life ballet stars such as Robbie Fairchild and Tiler Peck, enhancing the authenticity of its dance sequences.
As the first season unfolds, audiences are treated to stunning ballet performances, including choreography by acclaimed choreographer Christopher Wheeldon. These moments serve as a reminder of the artistry and dedication that define the world of dance. The show's blend of personal stories and breathtaking performances creates a captivating viewing experience.
In its exploration of the ballet world, Étoile invites viewers to appreciate the beauty and complexity of dance while also addressing the challenges faced by artists today. The Palladinos have crafted a series that not only entertains but also sparks conversations about the future of the arts.
As the season concludes, fans are left eager for more, with the potential for future seasons hinted at by Ward. While he remains coy about the show's direction, he assures audiences that exciting developments are on the horizon. Étoile is more than just a story about ballet; it is a celebration of the human spirit and the relentless pursuit of passion, making it a must-watch for fans of the Palladino's work and newcomers alike.
