Broadway’s acclaimed musical Oh, Mary! is about to experience another notable shift as Tituss Burgess steps in to portray Mary Todd Lincoln, succeeding Betty Gilpin, who exits the production on March 16, 2024. This change not only marks another chapter for the show but also showcases Burgess's dynamic return to the stage.
Initially, Gilpin took over the role from Cole Escola, who created the part of Mrs. Lincoln. The narrative of Oh, Mary! offers audiences a comic twist on history, positing Abraham Lincoln as a closeted gay man grappling with his social image, all the more complex with Todd Lincoln, portrayed by Burgess, expressing her frustration at being the president's 'beard' amid her aspiration to hit the limelight.
Reflecting on his casting, Burgess shared, "Oh, Mary! blew me away when I saw it on Broadway. Cole Escola is a genius!" His excitement about joining the production resonates with his deep appreciation for the creativity and humor it encapsulates. Burgess is no stranger to Broadway, having graced the stages of renowned productions including Moulin Rouge! and Guys and Dolls.
Burgess, who aims to bring his unique flair to Mary Todd Lincoln, expresses his heartfelt joy about joining the team at the Lyceum Theatre, emphasizing, "I understand the role of Mary Todd Lincoln maybe a little too well. I’m over the moon with joy." His extensive work spans both stage and screen, with recent appearances on Netflix’s animated musical Spellbound and the Apple TV+ series Schmigadoon!.
Originally premiering on Broadway on July 11, 2024, Oh, Mary! opened to considerable acclaim, becoming the first production at the Lyceum Theatre to gross over $1 million within just one week. The musical has repeatedly shattered its own box office records, exceeding expectations and enthralling audiences with its daring storyline and witty performances. Previously, the production enjoyed substantial success during its Off-Broadway run at the Lucille Lortel Theatre.
Directed by Tony Award nominee Sam Pinkleton, Oh, Mary! stands out not just for its innovative narrative twist, but also for its strong female lead’s perspective, allowing for a nuanced take on historical events. The transition from Gilpin to Burgess is expected to keep the production fresh and entertaining.
The casting change is sure to generate excitement among theatergoers and critics alike, as Burgess brings his charismatic energy and notable Broadway experience to the beloved role. With audiences eager to see how he interprets Mary Todd Lincoln, the show promises to remain one of the season’s must-see performances.
With Burgess stepping onto the stage, fans will likely find themselves even more invested in the story's portrayal of one of America's most misunderstood first ladies. His previous work showcases his range and depth, which will surely complement the existing dynamic of Oh, Mary!.
Overall, as Tituss Burgess prepares to take on this challenging and compelling role, his enthusiasm serves as a reminder of the vibrant spirit of Broadway’s current season, ready to enthrall audiences with each performance.