The Tennessee Titans made a bold move in this year’s free agency by signing former Pittsburgh Steelers left tackle Dan Moore Jr. to a lucrative four-year contract worth $82 million, including $50 million guaranteed. This decision has left many experts and fans alike questioning the value of the investment, particularly given Moore's inconsistent performance during his previous seasons.
Moore, who has been criticized for his lack of elite play, allowed a staggering 12 sacks and 41 pressures during the 2024 season. Analysts have expressed concern that this hefty contract does not reflect his contribution on the field, with Pro Football Focus identifying him as one of the most overpaid players of the free agency cycle. The site stated, “The Titans spent big on Moore, making him one of the 10 highest-paid tackles in the league.”
Despite having the worst season of his career in terms of protection, the Titans were in desperate need of improvements along their offensive line. This need pushed them into a position where they felt compelled to sign a player like Moore, whose potential they hope remains untapped. Analyst opinions suggest that while Moore may not have ranked among the top 40 tackles in the league at any point during his first four seasons, the Titans are banking on his potential growth as he transitions into their system.
With the signing of Moore, the Titans also plan to transition 2024 first-round pick JC Latham back to his original role at right tackle. This realignment of positions signals the team’s strategy to optimize its offensive line performance, facilitating a cohesive front that can better protect the quarterback and enhance the running game.
The Steelers’ decision to let Moore walk reflects a broader strategy of investing in younger talent. Pittsburgh will now rely on the development of their two first-round picks, Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu, who are expected to fill the void left by Moore's departure. This move aligns with a potential long-term strategy that prioritizes player development over immediate veteran experience.
In particular, Fautanu arrives with health concerns, having managed to start only one game while also spending time on injured reserve. Analysts will be watching closely to see how both he and Jones adapt to their new roles in hopes of mitigating the impact of Moore’s exit. Even though the Steelers may miss Moore’s experience, their decision to invest in youth could bear fruit in the coming years.
The skepticism surrounding Moore’s value is compounded by the comparative landscape of contracts within the league. Pro Football Focus, for instance, estimated his worth at $45 million over three years with only $28 million guaranteed. The Titans, however, chose to make a splash in free agency, fully believing in Moore's potential to rise above his prior performance and justify the financial commitment.
Many within the NFL community are divided regarding whether the Titans' heavy financial commitment will yield positive results. If Moore can meet or exceed expectations, he may indeed validate the Titans' investment. However, should he falter, the franchise could find itself further hampered by a mediocre offensive line without the funds to pursue better options in the future.
As the 2025 season approaches, Pittsburgh will continue to assess its path forward without Moore, focusing on the long-term development of their younger players. The Steelers have clearly outlined their priorities, favoring youth and potential over the immediate needs that an experienced player like Moore could have fulfilled.
The outcome of this high-stakes gamble for the Titans may not be evident until further into the season, as they strive to rebuild an offensive front that can adequately protect its quarterback and provide adequate running lanes. The hope for the franchise is that this strategic move reinforces their ambitions for competitiveness while enhancing Moore's career in the process.
In holding onto their young prospects, the Steelers may now be maximizing their value, giving themselves room to grow as they continue to transition into a new era. Wielding a developmental approach will require diligence and a strong focus on progression, but if executed correctly, it could yield significant rewards in the seasons to come.
As always, only time will tell how well Moore performs in Tennessee and whether the Titans' hefty investment will pay dividends on the field.
