Three Massachusetts women tragically lost their lives while vacationing in Belize, and recent investigations have revealed that carbon monoxide poisoning, likely caused by a faulty instant water heater, was the cause of their deaths. The women, identified as Wafae El Arar, 26, Imane Mallah, 24, and Kaoutar Naqqad, 23, were found dead in their hotel room at the Royal Kahal Beach Resort in San Pedro on February 22, 2025, after hotel staff entered the room following two days of unanswered door knocks.
Initially, Belizean authorities reported that the women died of "acute pulmonary edema," a condition characterized by fluid accumulation in the lungs. However, as the investigation progressed, it became clear that carbon monoxide was a significant factor. According to Gian Cho, executive director of the National Forensics Science Service, all three women had elevated levels of carboxyhemoglobin—higher than 60%—in their blood. For context, levels typically remain below 2% in non-smokers.
On March 26, 2025, the families of the deceased women issued a statement expressing their heartbreak while also voicing their gratitude for the thoroughness of the investigation. They stated, "While we remain shattered by the loss of these three bright lights in our world, we are incredibly heartened by the results of this investigation and grateful to those who completed it in a thorough and independent manner." They further emphasized their ongoing concerns regarding the initial handling of the case, which had raised suspicions about the circumstances surrounding the deaths.
Revere Mayor Patrick Keefe Jr. also commented on the situation, emphasizing that the families deserved the truth in their time of grief. He stated, "These young women were valued members of our community, and while the gravity of this tragedy weighs heavily on us all, I am grateful for the diligence of our state and federal partners in ensuring that a proper investigation was conducted and brought the truth to light." His sentiments reflect the broader community's mourning and the need for transparency in tragic events.
The investigation into the deaths has not only focused on the immediate cause but also on the circumstances surrounding the women's stay at the resort. Belize Police Commissioner Chester Williams noted that a second round of testing was conducted at the hotel after previous guests reported suspected carbon monoxide levels during their visits. This prompted officials to take action, leading to the temporary closure of the Royal Kahal Beach Resort.
Amidst the grief, the families of Naqqad, Mallah, and El Arar have been vocal about their desire for clarity. They expressed alarm at the initial lack of information and the media reports that suggested possible drug overdoses. In their statement, they said, "We continue to believe the deaths of Wafae, Imane, and Kaoutar are suspicious. We are hopeful the authorities will fulfill their responsibility to complete their reviews in a timely but thorough manner to ensure we know the full truth about what caused this tragedy." Their call for accountability highlights the importance of thorough investigations in ensuring that similar incidents do not occur in the future.
In addition to the Belizean investigation, the families are awaiting results from a separate independent review being conducted by Massachusetts authorities. This dual approach aims to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the events leading to the women's deaths.
During the investigation, authorities also recovered alcohol and gummies from the hotel room. While THC was found in one of the items, toxicology tests revealed no illicit substances in the women's bodies. This aspect of the investigation has raised questions about the initial assessments made by authorities, as the families continue to seek clarity and justice.
As the investigation unfolds, it has become evident that carbon monoxide poisoning remains a serious threat, particularly in environments where gas appliances are used. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) warns that carbon monoxide is an odorless, colorless gas produced during the combustion of fossil fuels, and accidental poisoning can lead to tragic outcomes.
The families of the three women have expressed their gratitude for the support they have received from friends, family, and the community. In their statement, they said, "We appreciate the privacy that has been extended to our families as we grieve and are also grateful to the media who have helped ensure that Wafae, Imane, Kaoutar and the impact of their loss are a central part of your news coverage." This acknowledgment of community support reflects the collective mourning and the desire for justice and understanding.
As the investigation continues, Belizean authorities are under pressure to provide a full account of how the situation was handled, particularly concerning the safety measures in place at the resort. The families have requested that authorities offer a clear explanation regarding the investigation's findings and the steps taken to ensure the safety of future guests.
In a world where travel can sometimes lead to unforeseen dangers, the tragic deaths of Wafae El Arar, Imane Mallah, and Kaoutar Naqqad serve as a stark reminder of the importance of safety and accountability in the hospitality industry. As the families navigate their unimaginable loss, they remain committed to uncovering the truth and ensuring that their loved ones are remembered not only for their vibrant lives but also for the circumstances surrounding their tragic deaths.
Ultimately, the hope is that this investigation will lead to meaningful changes in safety protocols and a greater awareness of the risks associated with carbon monoxide exposure, protecting future travelers from similar tragedies.
