Warning: This article includes MAJOR SPOILERS for The Life List!
Netflix's latest romantic dramedy, The Life List, featuring Sofia Carson, has captured the hearts of many viewers with its engaging premise and relatable characters. However, the film’s execution has sparked discussions about its format, leading some to believe that it would have been more effective as a television series rather than a two-hour movie.
In The Life List, Alex Rose, portrayed by Sofia Carson, embarks on a year-long journey to fulfill her childhood dreams after her mother, Elizabeth Rose, played by Connie Britton, encourages her to complete a life list. The concept of a life list—a compilation of goals one wishes to achieve—serves as a central theme throughout the film. This heartwarming premise resonates with many, but the story's execution has left some viewers wanting more.
Many feel that the film, while sweet and satisfying, simply had too much ground to cover in its limited runtime. The narrative rushes through significant moments, leaving viewers to fill in the emotional gaps. For example, while the film touches on Alex's experiences, it fails to delve deeply into how each item on her life list impacts her emotionally. "A TV show would’ve given the filmmakers more time to flesh out the characters and show Alex achieving her goals," observed a reviewer from Screen Rant, Rachel Lebonte.
Critics have noted that the film glosses over key details that could have added depth to the story. The audience is left in the dark about why Alex found herself in a rut or the circumstances surrounding her job loss. Such omissions make the narrative feel shallow and hinder emotional connections with the characters. The reviewer expressed frustration at how the film set up conflicts and questions without fully resolving them.
Despite these critiques, the performances of Sofia Carson and Connie Britton stand out. Both actresses bring heartfelt portrayals to their roles, with Britton’s character providing the emotional backbone for Alex's journey. The film also features a talented supporting cast, including Kyle Allen, who plays Bradley “Brad” Ackerman, and other characters like Julian and Garrett, who, while nuanced, are not given enough screen time to resonate with viewers.
In a recent interview, Connie Britton shared her own personal life list, reflecting on her dreams and aspirations. She expressed a desire to visit the Egyptian pyramids, a goal she has held since childhood. "There’s one that I have still not accomplished, which was on my list in childhood, which was I wanted to be an archaeologist and I really wanted to visit the Egyptian pyramids. I have not done that yet, so I would put that on my list today," Britton stated. She also humorously mentioned her wish to surf, despite doubting her abilities.
On the other hand, Kyle Allen revealed a rather unconventional aspiration related to acting legend Jackie Chan. "Behold. Let me tell you, I would like to be punched in the face. This side of my face, preferably by Jackie Chan, in a professional setting," he quipped, highlighting the playful nature of their conversation.
The film's synopsis hints at the emotional journey Alex undertakes as she uncovers family secrets, finds romance, and discovers herself along the way. While the premise is promising, the execution leaves much to be desired.
Many viewers have drawn comparisons between The Life List and other films like The To-Do List (2013), The Bucket List (2007), and Dash and Lily (2020), noting how these films more effectively explore their characters’ journeys. The Life List, despite its heartwarming moments, ultimately feels like a draft that could have benefited from more time and a longer format.
As the film continues to gain attention on Netflix, discussions about its format and storytelling choices are likely to persist. While the performances of the cast shine, many viewers are left wishing for a deeper exploration of the characters and their stories.
In a landscape where streaming platforms are increasingly investing in long-form storytelling, The Life List serves as a reminder that some narratives may be better suited for television. By allowing for more character development and exploration of themes, a series format could have transformed this heartfelt story into an even more impactful experience.
As audiences continue to engage with the film, it remains to be seen how the conversation around its format will evolve. For now, The Life List stands as a testament to the power of dreams and the importance of pursuing one’s goals, even if it leaves viewers wanting more.
