"The Electric State," Netflix's most ambitious release to date, directed by the Russo brothers, is a dystopian adventure set against the backdrop of the 1990s. Based on Simon Stålenhag's illustrated novel of the same name, the film introduces viewers to the gripping tale of Michelle (played by Millie Bobby Brown), who embarks on a perilous quest to find her long-lost brother, Christopher. Along the way, she teams up with Keats (Chris Pratt), a smuggler with stories to tell, and Cosmo, her trusty robot companion.
With CGI marvels and vibrant design, the film claims to have cost around $320 million, making it the most expensive film Netflix has ever produced. Critics have been quick to judge, with reviews ranking the film at just 14% on Rotten Tomatoes, though audiences offer it more favorably at 75% approval. This discrepancy highlights the divide between critics and everyday viewers on the film's execution and appeal.
"It has intriguing premise, cool cast, fantastic CGI, some lovable robot characters, and they are all shockingly underutilized," said critic Sneha Jaiswal, reflecting sentiments widely echoed among viewers. While the film features impressive visuals and brings to life a range of robot characters, there’s concern about the narrative failing to live up to these strengths. Notably, Stanley Tucci portrays Ethan Skate, the tech billionaire whose creations help humans dominate their robotic counterparts.
Many wonder about the tech development showcased along the way. "While the film has just 14% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, it also has very positive 75% from audiences," posits another review, as it recognizes collective audience enjoyment over professional critique. Critics have noted several weaknesses, including underdeveloped character arcs and humor falling flat at times.
The plot revolves around Michelle—an orphaned teen—on her search, reflecting on issues such as sentience and rebellion among robots against their human oppressors. The film springs forth on the premise of machines gaining awareness, which spirals the two societal factions toward conflict. The action is set against vibrant city lights, abandoned landscapes, and moral quandaries rooted deep within the story's foundation.
Across its runtime, which pushes nearly two hours, viewers encounter the challenges Michelle faces, from gangsters to government agents intent on controlling robotic characters like Mr. Peanut—a villainous figure voiced by Woody Harrelson. Within the film, elements feel repetitive, and the pacing lags, especially early on when the energy wanes due to its script.
Even review sentiments go both ways, as some hail the visual effects, stating, "The Electric State cost roughly $320 million to make," showing off where the investment appears to have gone. Notably, the stunning integration of robots amid humans offers eye-catching sequences. They can elicit wonder yet can fall victim to repetitive action sequences as the film progresses.
Voice performances add another layer, with Nutban providing his essence to the characters alongside Anthony Mackie voicing Cosmo. Meanwhile, audiences delight in glimpsing their favorite stars, such as Giancarlo Esposito and Ke Huy Quan, lending their vocal talents to supporting characters. A breakdown of salary reveals Brown making around $5 million, with Pratt at $20 million. These numbers reflect just how invested these performers are, hoping to draw from the film's future earnings.
Final ratings offer mixed interpretations, with some reviewers offering mediocre stars or reflections on how the film fell flat—one journalist affixing just one and half stars, stating it “lacks the spark and soul” to distinguish itself among the heavyweights on Netflix. Conversations around the film insist brightness and hope exist at its climax, stemming from nuanced discussions about what humanity holds versus what can be achieved through technology.
Despite criticisms, some filmmakers wish to engage with this narrative, citing, "The Electric State's voice cast is superb," showcasing the ensemble including numerous celebrated actors. Above all, the core story holds value even when its execution falters. While the film incubates stories woven with humor, adventure, and encounters with robots of dazzling varieties, whether or not it maintains lasting impressions is still up for debate.
Overall, audiences seeking entertainment might find satisfaction among the heart-pounding adventures of Michelle and her crew. Even with some flaws, the film stands as Netflix's bold exploration of what sci-fi can present when fused with the emotional depth associated with human authorship. Moving forward, fans hope for reflections or sequels to expand this technologically-infused narrative. Yet, whether it will achieve footing akin to classics remains uncertain as reviews navigate both horizons of delight and derision.
