Today : Mar 19, 2025
Arts & Culture
19 March 2025

The Alto Knights Explores Mafia Rivalry Through De Niro's Dual Role

Debra Messing takes on the role of Bobbie Costello in a film rich with drama and history.

Emmy-winning actor Debra Messing joins a talented ensemble in the new film The Alto Knights, showcasing the fierce competition between two of history's notorious mob bosses. Directed by Barry Levinson and written by Nicholas Pileggi, the film features Robert De Niro in a dual role as Frank Costello and Vito Genovese. Messing plays Frank's wife, Bobbie Costello, alongside Cosmo Jarvis as Vincent Gigante and Kathrine Narduci as Anna Genovese.

The storyline delves into the complexities of mob life and the power struggles that define its underworld. Using the backdrop of 1950s organized crime, The Alto Knights presents a gripping tale of ambition, betrayal, and the brutal tactics employed by its characters.

Robert De Niro, recognized for iconic roles in films like The Godfather Part II and Goodfellas, brings depth to both Costello and Genovese, illustrating their rivalry and contrasting methods. While Costello forged connections with politicians, Genovese's approach centered on violence and control. This tension highlights their journey from allies in the criminal empire established by Lucky Luciano to bitter enemies.

Their story dates back to the early 20th century, when both men began their rise in the criminal world under Luciano. Frank Costello, originally named Francesco Castiglia, arrived in America as a child and became a key player in Luciano's operations. After Luciano’s imprisonment in 1936, Costello assumed control as the acting boss of the Luciano crime family.

Meanwhile, Vito Genovese, another Italian immigrant, climbed the ranks to underboss but was forced to flee the U.S. following a murder charge. His return to America post-World War II saw him eager to reclaim power, culminating in a disastrous attempt to establish himself as the 'boss of bosses'. In 1946, Luciano bluntly informed Genovese that such a title was non-existent and that he still held the reins.

Despite these setbacks, Genovese plotted against Costello, recognizing that eliminating him was crucial for his ascendance. On May 2, 1957, this culminated in an assassination attempt when Vincent Gigante, under Genovese's orders, shot Costello as he entered a New York City lobby. Miraculously, Costello survived, only sustaining a grazing wound to the scalp. Costello's defiance was evident as he claimed, "Somebody tried to get me," when the attack unfolded. Notably, Gigante was acquitted of attempted murder after Costello refused to identify him.

In the aftermath of the failed assassination, Costello chose to retire from organized crime, effectively granting Genovese the control he sought, albeit temporarily. The power shift was short-lived; Genovese's reputation suffered following a failed meeting of mob leaders in Apalachin, New York, where authorities arrested several mafia members, putting a spotlight on his leadership.

Two years later, Genovese's fortunes took a further hit when he was convicted on drug charges, culminating in a 15-year prison sentence. Some speculated that rival mafia leaders had conspired against him, showcasing the treacherous nature of organized crime.

Throughout The Alto Knights, audiences are treated to a portrayal not just of mob life, but also of complex human relationships shaped by ambition and loyalty within the crime world. Debra Messing expressed her excitement about portraying Bobbie Costello, offering a glimpse into the societal roles women played in the lives of these powerful mobsters. "Working with De Niro is a dream come true," she noted, highlighting the unique dynamic of the film.

In bringing this story to life, Levinson and the cast offer both historical insight and dramatization, allowing modern audiences to appreciate the intricacies of mafia leadership and the consequences of power struggles. As the film approaches its release, anticipation surrounding its depiction of legendary figures like Costello and Genovese is palpable, resonating with those familiar with organized crime's storied history.