The second episode of Wer stiehlt mir die Show? aired on March 9, 2025, with Joko Winterscheidt returning as the host. This time, Teddy Teclebrhan stood out prominently during the episode, showcasing both his humor and improvisational skills. The episode featured various challenges, including the much-talked-about telephone call to Rea Garvey's father, which quickly turned the evening's entertainment to comedic gold.
The episode progressed through various entertaining categories, setting the stage for uproarious laughter and competitive spirit. The highlight arose during the unique ‘Hallo, wer quizz'n da?’ segment, where contestants had to call someone and impersonate them to extract answers to trivia questions. Notably, Teddy Teclebrhan took on the task of imitating Rea Garvey, leading to one of the most memorable moments of the night.
During the challenge, Teddy was tasked with calling Rea Garvey's father to learn which state Arnold Schwarzenegger was governor of. With just 60 seconds on the clock, Teddy successfully persuaded Rea's father to reveal the answer, "Kalifornien" (California), all the whilst pretending to be his son. His humorous approach, including declarations of love and intentions to pray, entertained both the audience and contestants.
"Der war sofort auf Knien" (He was immediately on his knees), Rea Garvey later recounted, as the amusing situation unfolded, leading to Teddy's quick-thinking improvisation. Despite the initial confusion brought on by Teddy's playful banter, Rea had to later clarify the matter via text message when his father hung up abruptly due to Teddy’s antics.
This entertaining display of wit was not just for laughs; it brought Teddy his first coin of the night. The competitive nature of the show, broadcast every Sunday at 8:15 PM on ProSieben and available earlier for subscribers on Joyn, shows how elements such as humor and challenge blend to create great entertainment.
Another entertaining part of the evening involved various quiz rounds where contestants struggled with questions such as "What is two to the power of five?" Leading with comic frustration, Teddy Teclebrhan recorded answers like ten and seven before eventually laughing off the confusion, endearing himself to both the viewers and his co-contestants.
Following the quiz, as the tensions increased toward the final segments, Heike Makatsch and Teddy Teclebrhan found themselves leading the charge against the other contestants, including rookie Wildcard candidate Derya.
Throughout the episode, the camaraderie and comedic exchanges among the contestants were notable. Teddy's ability to navigate through competitive challenges underscored his readiness to become the show’s breakout star. His zeal was reflected as he progressed through various rounds, taking the top spot with points accumulating from each challenge.
Throughout the episode, Joko Winterscheidt, as host, provided entertaining commentary on the contestants' struggles, keeping the energy vibrant. One of the more entertaining moments included Teddy named as the leader with 17 points, causing anticipation for the upcoming tiebreaker with Heike Makatsch and Rea Garvey, both holding 14 points each.
During the tiebreaker challenge, which involved measuring 50 centimeters on a tape devoid of numerical values, viewers were treated to the juxtaposed tension among competitors, as even minor variations could change the outcome. Heike emerged victorious by being closer to the measurement, securing her spot against Teddy for the final.
The ultimate face-off enabled Teddy Teclebrhan and Heike Makatsch to display their wit under pressure, culminating with quick-thinking quiz responses. Notably, Teddy outlasted Heike thanks to his successful guess of 'Buddha' when posed the question of Siddhartha Gautama.
Even though Joko reminisced slightly over Teddy’s correct response, he humorously noted, "Joko ist eher der Tennis-Typ" (Joko is more of the tennis type), recognizing the humorous dynamic established throughout the evening.
With Teddy's victory, the stage was set for his return as the host for future episodes, promising viewers more entertaining challenges and memorable antics, coupled with the infectious humor synonymous with Wer stiehlt mir die Show?. The episode garnered much attention for both the humor and the lighthearted competitive spirit, leaving fans eagerly awaiting the upcoming showdowns.