A major discussion is unfolding in Switzerland as lawmakers explore the implications of a potential ban on access to popular social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram for users under the age of 16. This examination stems from concerns about the effects of social media on young minds, with the Council of States approving two postulates on March 18, 2025, directing the federal government to investigate the impact of such restrictions.
Green Party MP Céline Vara has been vocal in her support for the initiative, arguing, "We protect children from cigarettes and alcohol, why not from social media?" She emphasized that the legislature's action is overdue, given the ongoing discussions about young people's mental health.
The recent initiative is not isolated; Australia has recently made headlines as the first country to outright ban access to TikTok and Instagram for under-16s, raising questions about whether similar measures could be effectively implemented in Switzerland.
Support for the motion is substantial, as further research has highlighted concerning trends among youth, including rising rates of depression and anxiety potentially linked to social media use. Another prominent figure in this debate, Green deputy Maya Graf, has called for a ban on smartphone access in schools, supporting her argument with scientific evidence. Graf pointed out that, "In recent years, research has shown that smartphones not only disrupt the development of children and adolescents, but also harm their mental health while severely limiting their ability to concentrate and learn."
She referenced a study that revealed a stark increase in rates of depression, anxiety disorders, and suicidal thoughts among young people in tandem with the growth of mobile phone usage.
Such concerns echo a survey conducted by the Tamedia media group, which revealed that 78 percent of Swiss respondents favor a more restrictive approach to social media usage for the youth. This widespread inclination among the public indicates a growing awareness of the challenges posed by social media.
The decision on whether to implement a full or limited ban on access to social media platforms now rests with the Federal Council, which will assess the existing evidence and recommendations made by lawmakers. How these rules might be enacted is yet to be fully determined, primarily as educational regulations regarding smartphone use may fall under the jurisdiction of individual cantons rather than federal oversight.
This is not the only significant issue the Swiss government is dealing with. On the same day, March 18, an army armored personnel carrier was involved in an accident in Canton Bern, resulting in injuries to three members of the army. That incident underscores the diverse challenges facing Swiss authorities, from social media regulation to military oversight.
Furthermore, while social media access remains a contentious subject, discussions about gun control and military preparedness are also heating up. The Swiss parliament recently backed proposals for expanding the armaments company Nitrochemie to boost defense capabilities, indicating a focus on national security in tandem with youth safety. These actions reflect a multifaceted approach to governance as lawmakers navigate the intricate balance between safeguarding children online and ensuring the nation’s defense.
In this continually evolving conversation regarding minors and their online exposure, the dialogue initiated by Swiss lawmakers indicates a critical moment of reassessment. Are current practices sufficient, or is a total or partial ban on these popular platforms necessary to protect the mental health of children? As the situation unfolds, the public and policymakers alike may be left pondering what the best path forward is.
