The Pittsburgh Steelers have had an eventful offseason filled with significant roster moves aimed at bolstering the team ahead of the 2025 NFL season. At the heart of these changes is the high-profile acquisition of star receiver DK Metcalf, who was traded from the Seattle Seahawks and granted a five-year, $150 million contract, marking a franchise-record extension.
General Manager Omar Khan and Assistant GM Andy Weidl have worked diligently during the legal tampering period to enhance the team's roster. Alongside Metcalf, who brings explosive talent to the field, the Steelers have also signed veteran cornerbacks Darius Slay and Brandin Echols, linebacker Malik Harrison, running back Kenneth Gainwell, safety Juan Thornhill, and re-signed defensive lineman Isaiahh Loudermilk, among others. Such roster moves illustrate the Steelers’ proactive approach to the upcoming season.
However, amidst these exciting signings, the team is still faced with a significant question mark at the quarterback position, with 41-year-old Aaron Rodgers yet to make a decision regarding his future. While the Steelers also brought back Mason Rudolph on a two-year deal to provide some stability under center, the uncertainty surrounding the quarterback situation looms large over the team's ambitions.
Former NFL GM Mike Tannenbaum expressed skepticism over the Steelers’ offseason decisions, calling them the “most head-scratching” moves so far. “The events in Pittsburgh. The DK Metcalf trade and extension is understandable, especially in light of George Pickens going into the final year of his contract,” Tannenbaum noted. However, he also emphasized that until the quarterback position is settled, “everything else is irrelevant.” This sentiment highlights the critical impact that the starting QB will have on the team's overall success.
With Metcalf now on the roster, concerns arise regarding the arrangement of the receiving core, specifically concerning George Pickens, who has also made a name for himself. Pro Football Focus analyst Mason Cameron pointed out that while the Metcalf acquisition is impressive, it may lead to redundancy given the similar skill sets both players possess as downfield threats. Cameron compared Metcalf and Pickens, noting, “They both can be volatile emotionally, too.” Yet, Metcalf’s track record as a reliable No. 1 receiver cannot be overlooked, boasting at least 900 receiving yards in each of his NFL seasons.
The remainder of the offseason strategy has focused on shoring up other positional needs. The signing of veteran cornerback Darius Slay has received praise, especially considering his experience and successful track record with the Philadelphia Eagles. PFF’s Cameron referred to the one-year deal worth $10 million as the Steelers' best move, asserting that Slay will bring a quality veteran presence to a young secondary.
“Entering his age-34 season, Slay won’t have to travel far to play for his new team,” Cameron noted. “He’s a quality veteran cornerback with a consistent coverage profile, having produced a 75.0-plus PFF grade in three of his past four seasons.” Slay’s performance statistics, including 12 pass breakups in the previous season, underscore his value to the Steelers’ defense as they gear up for the upcoming campaign.
Additionally, the Steelers have signed Esezi Otomewo, a former fifth-round pick from the Minnesota Vikings who recently played with the Jacksonville Jaguars. Otomewo is set to bolster Pittsburgh's defensive tackle depth, joining a competitive group that includes Cameron Heyward and Keeanu Benton. The Steelers’ interior defensive linemen now also include Dean Lowry, Daniel Ekuale, Montravious Adams, and Jacob Slade.
With the 21st overall pick in the upcoming NFL draft still in their possession, the Steelers have options to further enhance their roster, especially at defensive tackle. Prospects like Kenneth Grant from Michigan and Walter Nolen from Ole Miss are anticipated to be on their radar.
Despite the addition of new talent, the team has also seen some departures, losing key players such as Kyle Allen, Najee Harris, and Justin Fields. These transitions have raised questions among fans and analysts alike about the team's direction heading into the new season.
The signing of Juan Thornhill adds yet another dimension to the Steelers’ offseason story. The 29-year-old safety recently transitioned from the Cleveland Browns after they released him, and he brings two Super Bowl rings from his previous stint with the Kansas City Chiefs. In six NFL seasons, Thornhill has recorded eight interceptions, contributing valuable experience to a defense that finished eighth in DVOA last year.
Overall, the Steelers’ offseason has been both a mix of excitement and uncertainty, particularly as they await a definitive resolution in the quarterback market. As the franchise navigates through this legal tampering period, all eyes remain on free agent signings and draft decisions that will ultimately shape the team’s future as they aim to contend in the formidable AFC North.
