Sir Keir Starmer has defended his premiership during the first five months in office, insisting he would not alter his approach amid growing criticism from multiple fronts. Facing UK MPs during a lengthy question session, Starmer underscored the necessity of difficult decisions surrounding tax hikes and cuts to benefits, explaining these were pivotal to stabilizing public finances previously impacted by conservative policies.
"We had to do tough stuff, we're getting on with it," Starmer remarked, responding to queries about changes to farmers' inheritance tax and adjustments to winter fuel payments. He also addressed the need for patience concerning his strategies for economic revitalization, acknowledging it may take some time for citizens to experience tangible improvements.
The Prime Minister linked his economic ambitions to G7 comparisons, asserting his commitment to achieving the highest sustained growth among major economies by the next election. Recent evaluations from the Bank of England revealed disappointing economic performance, with no growth tracked between October and December, raising skepticism about his aspirations.
Starmer maintained optimism, citing the introduction of higher minimum wages and discussing regulations and technology like artificial intelligence as measures to support economic metrics. He faced pointed questions from select committee chairs, particularly concerning the backlash to recent litigation and financial decisions.
During another notable meeting on December 12, European Council President António Costa visited Downing Street. Their discussions reaffirmed both leaders' commitment to tighter UK-EU relations, primarily focusing on collaboration amid global uncertainties. Costa extended an invitation for Starmer to attend the informal EU leadership meeting on February 3, deepening bilateral ties.
At the meeting, Starmer and Costa explored prevailing geopolitical dynamics, including unwavering support for Ukraine and other challenges, like the Middle Eastern conflict. They committed to upholding the foundational status of the Withdrawal Agreement and other collaborative frameworks, gearing up for significant milestones, including the EU-UK Summit set for early 2025.
Despite these political engagements, back at home, Starmer's leadership faced internal revolt. Labour MPs have expressed concerns over his decisions impacting social welfare, such as the abolition of universal winter fuel payments—a move many considered regressive—leaving millions of pensioners vulnerable.
The backlash escalated recently following another controversial announcement connected to pension updates, reigniting frustrations over Labour's shift from its previous stances. Former supporters were left confused as the party chose not to honour pledges related to the women born in the 1950s who were affected by changes to the state pension age.
Starmer attempted to clarify the motivations behind these announcements, stating it had not been fair to promise compensation for these women due to budget constraints, citing potential costs running upwards of tens of billions. Nevertheless, the discontent from Labour circles has highlighted the potential risks of alienation from key voter demographics.
Negative polling results add pressure on Starmer’s administration, with YouGov reporting he has become one of Britain’s least popular politicians, even ranking unfavourably against his predecessor Jeremy Corbyn. Political analysts regard this erosion of support as particularly concerning and note deliberations speculating whether Starmer can reignite faith among voters before the next electoral challenge.
While joking with journalists at his recent Downing Street reception, Starmer acknowledged being self-aware about perceptions of his leadership but hinted at optimism for shifting views once his government implements beneficial changes across the economy, healthcare, and living standards. Starmer's strategy focusing on present sacrifices for future gains appears to be bearing weight on his cabinet as they navigate through the public’s scrutiny.
He iterated, "It will take time, of course it will," when pressed about when citizens would begin to feel the results of his administration, urging calm. Starmer, drawing from nine years of political experience, illustrated his desire to govern effectively compared to his previous years spent losing votes and battling as the opposition.
Many Labour figures remain skeptical, questioning his decision-making process and political timing, but those close to Starmer express confidence, indicating time might swing perceptions positively if he can deliver on key campaign promises.
The challenging economic forecasts continue to loom, especially with indications from the Bank of England warning of stagnation. Starmer’s predictions conflict with expectations, painting him as hopeful yet under increased scrutiny.
He stated, "One of the biggest mistakes I think was the idea everything could be fixed by Christmas. It can’t," underlining the long path he believes is necessary for economic recovery and reform. The Summer Spending Review is anticipated to be transformative, determining Labour’s future public expenditure and strategic priorities.
Despite these tumultuous beginnings, Starmer’s supporters argue there remains optimism as the Conservative party continues to face their own polling issues. The challenge for the Labour leader will undoubtedly lie in turning public sentiment around before the next election, making his first five months as Prime Minister pivotal for determining his political future.
