New speculation is swirling around Sandro Tonali, as rumors suggest the talented midfielder may exit Newcastle United for Juventus as early as the January 2025 transfer window. Following what can only be described as a tumultuous first season for the 24-year-old at St. James' Park, his motivation to explore new opportunities seems to be growing.
According to Sky Sports' journalist Sacha Tavolieri, the Italian international is contemplating leaving the Magpies after facing challenges securing regular minutes. Tonali's arrival at Newcastle was met with considerable fanfare last summer, with the club splashing £55 million to lure him from AC Milan. Since then, injuries and disciplinary issues—including a lengthy ten-month ban for betting violations—have impacted his playtime. This season, he has appeared in only 51% of available minutes, collecting just two assists across the Premier League.
His frustrations have prompted Juventus to rekindle interest, with reports indicating they view Tonali as a key asset to bolster their midfield. They aim to cement his transfer by making necessary player sales to raise the estimated €55 million, or approximately £48 million, fee Newcastle reportedly seeks. Juventus is also considering selling midfielder Nicolo Fagioli and Kenan Yildiz, which could help fund Tonali's move. Yildiz, being sought after, could net the club €35-40 million, significantly easing the financial burden of Tonali's prospective purchase.
Despite the mounting interest from Juventus, Newcastle’s hierarchy has made it clear they are eager to retain Tonali, especially amid speculation about potential rental agreements. The club views the Italian playmaker as central to their future plans as they look to compete at higher levels.
Tavolieri notes, "The relationship between the Italian playmaker and Newcastle feels like it is nearing its end," adding weight to reports of his unrest. Newcastle fans, holding high hopes for their team’s success, would undoubtedly be disappointed to see the player depart, particularly as he showcased flashes of brilliance prior to his suspension.
While Tonali’s dissatisfaction is reportedly under control—his representatives have denied claims of discontent—the nature of his contract, earning £120,000 per week, heightens scrutiny. The player’s exposure is limited when surrounded by stars like Bruno Guimaraes, Joelinton, Joe Willock, and Sean Longstaff, potentially stoking discontent.
Juventus's coach Tiago Motta is also aware of Tonali’s ambitions and sentiments, acknowledging the young star’s desire to reclaim his place among Italy's football elite. Tonali’s situation reflects wider challenges at Newcastle as the squad grapples with adapting to the Premier League's rigors, especially after investing heavily last summer.
The Magpies are also bracing for potential challenges revolving around more core players, with Guimaraes drawing interest from other clubs, including Manchester City. The dynamics surrounding the squad are complex, with tensions rising as Newcastle pushes for pivotal victories, such as their upcoming quarterfinal against Brentford and league matches against Ipswich Town.
Fans are still reeling from Tonali's earlier scoring exploits, and as they prepare for pivotal fixtures, anticipation looms over the team’s immediate future and the player’s role. With plans and performances yet to settle, hopes remain high for both Tonali’s retention and Newcastle’s quest for silverware.
What the next steps will be remains to be seen. Still, as transfer windows loom, corners of football are never quiet, and speculation surrounding Sandro Tonali will only grow amid the noise of January's hustle and bustle.
