The NFL is gearing up for potential changes ahead of the 2025 season, spurred by new proposals from several teams. Notably, the Green Bay Packers and Detroit Lions have put forth rule alterations that aim to enhance the dynamics of the game. Among the proposed changes include a call to ban the infamous "tush push" and adjustments to playoff seeding that would impact how teams are positioned in the postseason.
On March 19, 2025, the Lions initiated a request to revamp the way playoff teams are seeded. The current system automatically places all division winners in the top four spots, regardless of their records. The Lions' proposal suggests that playoff slots should be determined by a team's win-loss record, which could significantly alter postseason matchups. This adjustment could have changed last season’s outcomes, particularly for the Minnesota Vikings, who were forced to play a wildcard game against the Rams despite having a considerably higher record than their opponent.
In addition, the Packers submitted a proposal to ban the "tush push" maneuver, a controversial play that has gained traction in recent seasons. Known for its effectiveness, particularly for the Philadelphia Eagles who have employed it using quarterback Jalen Hurts, this play involves players pushing the quarterback forward to gain necessary yardage. Packers general manager Brian Gutekunst has emphasized that the desire to ban this tactic is partly driven by concerns for player safety and the pace of the game.
The details of the proposed ban specify that no offensive player may "immediately at the snap, push or throw his body against a teammate, who was lined up directly behind the snapper and received the snap, to aid him in an attempt to gain yardage." Violating this rule would result in a 10-yard penalty, addressing the tactical benefits this play has provided to teams that utilize it successfully.
The recent proposals go beyond just these two significant rule changes. The Eagles have also suggested modifications the overtime rules to provide both teams the opportunity to score, which mirrors the current playoff formats where both squads can have their chance at possession. Presently, if a team scores a touchdown during the initial possession of overtime, the game ends without the other team getting a chance to respond. League executive Troy Vincent highlighted the trend showing that receiving teams have a substantial advantage—56.8% of overtime games from 2017 to 2024 were won by the team that received the ball first, compared to 55.4% from 2001 to 2011.
Along with these proposals, the Lions have tackled the issue of defensive penalties, aiming to eliminate automatic first downs for defensive holding and illegal contact fouls. This current rule grants a five-yard penalty along with a new set of downs to the offense, a situation the Lions view as overly punitive against defenses.
Fans have reacted positively to the Lions' proposal, with many expressing their support online. One fan noted, "FINALLY!!! The automatic first down is the biggest advantage defensive penalty... I’ve never understood why the offense gets three free new shots." Others echoed this sentiment, indicating a desire to see defensive penalties addressed differently.
Additionally, the Pittsburgh Steelers have proposed a new protocol allowing teams one video or phone call with prospective unrestricted free agents during the negotiation window prior to the beginning of the league year. This would enable a more direct engagement between teams and players while still maintaining current restrictions on communication.
Furthermore, the Lions have also suggested that players placed on injured reserve, specifically those designated to return, should not count towards the 90-man roster limit until the cutdowns on days leading up to the regular season.
Teams are optimistic that these proposals will foster a more balanced competition and enhance the overall excitement of NFL games. The upcoming league meetings will be crucial for turning these suggestions into actionable reforms, needing approval from at least 24 out of 32 team owners.
Meanwhile, the Washington Commanders have raised the issue of obtaining scouting credentials for games during the final weeks of the regular season. They propose to standardize scouting access for playoff hopefuls, ensuring all teams in the hunt have equal opportunity to prepare for potential opponents.
With various fronts of competition being addressed, these proposed changes could usher in a new era for the NFL, focusing on fair play, player safety, and more engaging game dynamics. It will be interesting to see how the league and team owners respond as they discuss these critical topics at the upcoming meetings.
