Netflix’s latest offering, American Primeval, has quickly become one of the standout successes of the year, drawing viewers with its gripping portrayal of the Utah War. Starring Taylor Kitsch, known for his role on Friday Night Lights, the series has captivated audiences eager for fresh narratives since the popularity of Yellowstone and its spin-offs. With creator Peter Berg and writer Mark L. Smith at the helm, discussions are already swirling around the potential for future seasons.
“We started the show without knowing exactly who’s going to live and who’s going to die at the end... But who knows? I was sad, and Taylor was sad when we told him,” said Berg, reflecting on the show’s intense and unpredictable character arcs. The show, like other successful limited series Westerns, features brutal storytelling, and as fans of such genres know, not many characters make it through alive. Kitsch’s character, Isaac, meets his tragic end as he battles to protect Sara (Betty Gilpin) and her son Devin (Preston Mota). By the finale, only they, along with mountain man Jim Bridger (Shea Whigham), remain to ride off toward California, marking the end of harrowing journeys.
The narrative weaves the harsh realities of 1857 America, exploring conflicts among pioneers, the Mormon militia, and Native Americans. Kitsch describes his character as somewhat of a protector. Reflecting on his experiences, he said, “It’s very different from what I’ve done. I think you’re always chasing the risks and the unpredictability of it. I just love the rawness of it.” He connects deeply with Isaac’s role, admitting, “There is a bit of [the protector] in me.”
The ensemble cast adds considerable depth to the series, featuring notable performances by Dane DeHaan as devout Mormon Jacob Pratt and Derek Hinkey as Shoshone warrior Red Feather. Each character contributes to the multifaceted portrayal of this turbulent historical period.
Berg's vision for the series often leaves viewers questioning the balance between historical representation and dramatized storytelling. The narrative strongly revolves around fundamentalist violence, particularly the Mountain Meadows Massacre, where Mormon militia, aided by the Paiute tribe, committed one of the worst atrocities of the time, resulting in close to 140 deaths. This shocking element raises important questions about the series’ reception, especially among audiences familiar with the cultural backdrop. “How will it play in Utah?” mused The Wall Street Journal, hinting at the sensitive portrayal of this dark chapter.
Kitsch has invested considerable effort to prepare for his role, including spending time with Native American elders and learning Shoshoni. “I got to spend time down in Wind River with some of the elders there and learn to speak Shoshoni, and educate myself and a lot of what happened,” Kitsch revealed, highlighting the importance of cultural authenticity. This immersion provided him with unique insights, enriching his portrayal of Isaac, as he balanced the character's rugged exterior with emotional depth.
His preparation did not stop there; Kitsch also worked with a shaman to achieve the right mental state for filming. “I still work with him on a personal level. My father passed away during shooting, so [the shaman] helped me with...that, a lot.” The actor's commitment to authenticity meant taking on new skills, including horse riding, presenting additional challenges during filming, especially with his previously broken foot. “I was in a boot for much of the show,” he shared, signifying the physical demands the role required. “When these horses and you’re in a couple of feet of snow, anything can f--king happen,” he added, humorously noting the unpredictability of filming on location.
Looking toward the future, fans of the series are eager to know whether American Primeval will return for a second season. The creative team has hinted at the possibility of exploring other stories within the anthological framework of American history. Berg confirmed, “We’re talking about it right now. That’s the way we’d go if we do it... the idea of looking backwards is really interesting to me.” This openness to future narratives leaves fans hopeful for what’s to come once this season concludes.
Overall, American Primeval presents not only thrilling action but also examines the sociopolitical climate of the 19th century, wrapping it with rich character development, emotional stakes, and cultural authenticity, all of which strike chords with its audiences.