On March 27, 2025, Netflix expanded its library by adding the two-part serial See No Evil: The Moors Murders, a gripping retelling of one of the most notorious crime stories in British history. Originally aired on ITV in 2006, this drama chronicles the chilling events surrounding the Moors murders, which took place between July 1963 and October 1965, committed by the infamous duo Myra Hindley and Ian Brady.
Starring Maxine Peake as Hindley and Sean Harris as Brady, the series is told through the eyes of Maureen Smith, Hindley’s sister, portrayed by Joanne Froggatt. The narrative dives deep into the harrowing experiences of the victims’ families, particularly focusing on the emotional turmoil faced by Smith and her husband David, played by Matthew McNulty.
The Moors murders shocked the nation, with five children—Pauline Reade, John Kilbride, Keith Bennett, Lesley Ann Downey, and Edward Evans—aged between 10 and 17, falling prey to Hindley and Brady. At least four of these young victims were sexually assaulted, leading to widespread media coverage and public outrage. Hindley was infamously dubbed ‘the most evil woman in Britain’ and received a life sentence for her crimes, while Brady, a diagnosed psychopath, also received a life sentence before dying in 2017 at the age of 79. Hindley passed away in 2002 after serving 36 years in prison.
See No Evil marked a significant moment in television history, being the first dramatization of these grim murders. It was created to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the trial of Hindley and Brady, and the production was marked by two years of meticulous research. Writer Neil McKay conducted interviews with detectives involved in the case, as well as relatives of the murdered children, ensuring that the portrayal was both respectful and accurate. The series was made with the support of the victims’ families, a decision that added a poignant layer to the storytelling.
When it first aired on ITV, See No Evil attracted over 6 million viewers for each episode, a testament to the public's enduring interest in the case. The series received critical acclaim and won the BAFTA TV award for Best Drama Serial in 2007. McKay described the show as providing a "sober, unsensational account of the most notorious crimes of the last century," emphasizing its focus not only on the heinous acts but also on their impact on the victims' families.
Viewers have continued to express their thoughts on the drama since its original release. One user on IMDB remarked, "This was a superb, well written very emotive drama. It handled a very difficult subject with sensitivity and respect. An excellent piece of factual drama, well worth a viewing." Another viewer, initially skeptical about dramatizations of recent true crimes, found the series "intelligently written" and praised its focus on the effects of the crimes on those around the killers rather than sensationalizing the murders themselves. This perspective resonates with many who appreciate a more nuanced approach to such dark subject matter.
As the series is now available for streaming on Netflix, it has reignited discussions about the Moors murders and the complex legacy left by Hindley and Brady. The drama's portrayal of the emotional fallout from these crimes serves as a reminder of the human cost of such brutality. With its blend of historical accuracy and dramatic storytelling, See No Evil continues to engage audiences and provoke thought about the nature of evil and its impact on society.
In addition to the compelling performances by Peake, Froggatt, and Harris, the series stands out for its careful attention to detail. McKay’s writing is informed by extensive research and interviews, which adds depth to the characterizations and story arcs. The focus on the victims’ families, particularly Maureen Smith’s journey, offers a lens through which viewers can understand the long-lasting effects of tragedy.
Since its release, both Peake and Froggatt have continued to build impressive careers, with Peake appearing in notable series such as Little Dorrit, Silk, and Black Mirror, while Froggatt is well-known for her roles in Downton Abbey and Liar. Their performances in See No Evil remain among their most impactful, showcasing their ability to convey complex emotions in the face of unimaginable horror.
As Netflix continues to curate a collection of classic British dramas, See No Evil: The Moors Murders stands out as a significant work that not only entertains but also educates viewers about one of the darkest chapters in British criminal history. The series invites reflection on the nature of crime, justice, and the enduring pain of loss, making it a poignant addition to any viewing list.
In a world where true crime stories often veer into sensationalism, See No Evil offers a refreshing approach that prioritizes the voices of those affected by the crimes. As audiences revisit this series on Netflix, it serves as a reminder of the importance of storytelling that honors the memories of the victims while grappling with the complexities of human nature.
