Myles Garrett is remaining in Cleveland after the Browns signed him to a record-breaking four-year extension on March 9, 2025. The deal, worth $160 million overall, makes him the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history, averaging $40 million per year with $123.5 million guaranteed. This substantial contract marks not only a significant financial achievement but also reflects the team’s desire to keep their key player amid prior trade discussions.
Garrett, who requested a trade from the Browns on February 3, 2025, expressed his initial frustrations with the team's direction, stating, "While I've loved calling this city my home, my desire to win and compete on the biggest stages won't allow me to be complacent." His trade request fueled speculation and concern among fans and analysts about his future with the franchise, particularly as Cleveland has struggled to find success, only reaching the playoffs twice since drafting him number one overall in 2017.
Initially, Garrett's future was uncertain, with both sides appearing reluctant to make any concessions. The ripple effects of his decision were widely discussed as general manager Andrew Berry made clear at the NFL Combine his commitment to keeping Garrett, saying he could not envision circumstances where trading him would be beneficial.
Despite the tension, discussions shifted over time. Garrett and his agent, Nicole Lynn, worked closely with Berry to finalize the lucrative contract. Lynn commented, "Myles had a change of heart... he’s excited to go from Cleveland to Canton and chase a championship." The negotiations took the urgency of free agency's impending start and culminated within 36 hours, allowing Garrett to focus on strengthening the team as he embarks on the next chapter of his career with the Browns.
The details of Garrett's new contract include $100 million to be paid within the first three years, $1 million annually as workout bonuses, and $88.8 million classified as execution guarantees. These terms not only affirm his position as one of the elite defensive players, but they also reset the market for non-quarterback salaries, surpassing the previous high set by Las Vegas Raiders edge rusher Maxx Crosby, who signed for $35.5 million annually just days earlier.
Garrett's impressive resume includes four All-Pro selections, six Pro Bowl appearances, and accolades as the 2023 Defensive Player of the Year. He has consistently demonstrated his skill by achieving double-digit sacks during seven of his eight seasons with Cleveland, amassing 102.5 sacks over 117 games played. Yet, amid his personal success, the quest for playoff wins remained elusive. Garrett expressed his hope for more postseason opportunities, stating, "The goal was never to go from Cleveland to Canton, it has always been to compete for and win a Super Bowl."
The agreement also features a no-trade clause, solidifying Garrett's position with the Browns for now and preventing any potential moves for the length of the contract, which runs through 2030. This deal not only protects the team's cornerstone player but also boosts morale among fans who have witnessed years of ups and downs.
Garrett's new contract is expected to have ramifications beyond his own situation. With Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver Ja'Marr Chase and others now eyeing contract renewals, the market figures to be adjusted yet again. The Bengals have even stated aspirations toward making Chase the highest-paid player of his kind, meaning teams will have to contend with the standards set by Garrett's contract.
For the Browns, this substantial commitment signifies their intent to remain competitive and their dedication to building around Garrett as they navigate future seasons. Historically, the franchise has been mired in mediocrity since their rebirth, and securing Garrett allows them to establish stability and direction.
Looking forward, Garrett will likely continue to terrorize AFC North opponents such as the Bengals, Steelers, and Ravens, against whom he has tallied impressive statistics. Specifically, he recorded 13 sacks each against the Bengals and Steelers, solidifying his status as a formidable edge rusher. With Garrett’s new deal, he becomes both the highest-paid non-quarterback and the face of the franchise, ensuring Cleveland fans have reason to remain hopeful as they anticipate the upcoming seasons.
Overall, the resolution of Garrett’s trade request and the subsequent deal mark both sides' commitment to overcome past tensions and look toward shared goals. The Browns' faith in their star pass rusher as they strive for greater accomplishments has been rewarded, and Garrett’s aspirations for Super Bowl contention are back on track. The stakes for the 2025 NFL season have never been higher for both player and franchise as they aim to capitalize on this renewed partnership.