On February 7, 2025, renowned Parisian lawyers Julia Minkowski and Marie Dosé appeared on the popular talk show "C à Vous," broadcast on France 5, to discuss their new book titled "Éloge de la présomption d'innocence" (Praise of the Presumption of Innocence). This book aims to shed light on the fundamental legal principle of presumption of innocence and its indispensable place within modern French society.
During the discussion led by host Anne-Elisabeth Lemoine, the lawyers stressed the concerning trend they see in contemporary judicial discourse—that of presumed guilt, overshadowing the innocent until proven guilty principle. Minkowski elucidated, "Il y a une présomption de culpabilité aujourd'hui," illustrating their perceptions of increasing public and judicial pressures to view individuals as guilty before sufficient evidence has been established.
The legal duo's insights were not limited to their book's publication; they have been actively promoting its themes through various media channels to highlight the erosion of judicial safeguards. Minkowski and Dosé, experienced criminal defense lawyers, underscored their dedication to educating the public about the presumption of innocence. They believe the general populace often misunderstands its importance within the criminal justice framework.
Marie Dosé highlighted the constitutional aspect of the presumption, stating emphatically, "C'est à l'accusation de prouver la culpabilité," reinforcing the idea it is the burden of proof lying squarely with the prosecution, not the defense. This notable legal distinction, they argue, has become increasingly blurred amid rising public disdain for alleged offenders, often exacerbated by sensational media coverage and social media discourse.
Throughout their public appearances, the lawyers have expressed concern over what they perceive as society's deep-seated appetite for condemnation—an appetite they argue stems from cultural trends favoring punitive over rehabilitative justice. Julia Minkowski depicted societal dynamics where "il y a une appétence ... à trouver des boucs émissaires" reflecting on the rise of disenfranchisement leading to scapegoat mentality against accused individuals. This sentiment, they warn, can dangerously pivot the public's judgment from the established legal standards.
They highlighted the intersection of these issues with movements like #MeToo, which, according to Minkowski, presents challenges as well as provides legitimate platforms for addressing sexual harassment and abuse. While she recognizes the movement’s significance, she articulates the importance of maintaining judicial fairness. She cautioned, "Chacun peut croire qui il veut ... sans qu'elle n'ait été vérifiée," stressing the inherent danger of unverified accusations undermining the very fabric of justice and due process.
The discussions taking place on platforms like "C à Vous" are part of broader dialogues about justice within the social and legal realms. By sharing their expertise and perspectives, Minkowski and Dosé seek not only to promote their book but to inspire vigilant discourse around legal rights, particularly the fundamental principle of presumption of innocence.
By raising awareness through these media appearances, Minkowski and Dosé hope to reinforce the urgency for both the legal field and society to uphold one of its most cherished principles, ensuring it is not sacrificed at the altar of public sentiment or hastily formed judgments.
Their public efforts reflect not just the ambitions encapsulated within their text, but also the pressing necessity for individuals to comprehend their rights under law fully. The attention surrounding "Éloge de la présomption d'innocence" and the insights shared on shows like "C à Vous" prompt viewers to engage thoughtfully with ideas of justice and ethics. With increasing pressures facing defendants and suspects, grounding discussions around the presumption of innocence is more necessary than ever.
Through their presence in various media, Julia Minkowski and Marie Dosé continue to champion the presumption of innocence, advocating for its protection against the tides of cultural shifts and judicial scrutiny.