The new Netflix series La Palma has climbed to the top of the streaming charts, captivating viewers with its dramatic portrayal of disaster, yet leaving many questioning the line between fact and fiction. Released on December 12, 2024, the show revolves around a Norwegian family whose vacation on the idyllic island of La Palma takes a terrifying turn amid volcanic havoc.
Created by Martin Sundland, Lars Gudmestad, and Harald Rosenløw Eeg, La Palma features a talented cast including Ingrid Bolsø Berdal, Anders Baasmo, Alma Günther, Ólafur Darri Ólafsson, and Thea Sofie Loch Næss. The series comprises four binge-worthy episodes, perfect for viewers seeking immersive storytelling.
The show's official synopsis describes the tension: “A Norwegian family vacationing on La Palma faces disaster when a young researcher discovers alarming signs of an imminent volcanic eruption.” This dramatic setup has propelled La Palma to surprising heights, overtaking established hits such as Jamie Foxx's stand-up special and Lisa Kudrow's dark comedy.
While the show has topped Netflix’s viewing charts, it has also faced significant backlash. With only 33% on Rotten Tomatoes, many viewers have taken to social media to express their displeasure. Comments range from outrageous disbelief—"Watched La Palma on Netflix and pure sh*t what do you mean she survived a tsunami inside an airplane??" by user @adrianthestan—to cutting critiques about the show being overly dramatized and unrealistic.
Reviewers have split opinions, some deriding its plot conveniences, but others acknowledging its thrilling survival narrative. One review noted, “Character development is uneven and there are some unbelievable plot conveniences, but the stunning visuals... work to offset the shortcomings.” Meanwhile, others have found the series so bad it’s good, cheering on its melodramatic moments.
The real La Palma, where the series is set, is known for its volcanic activity, particularly the Cumbre Vieja, which last erupted dramatically from September to December 2021. This real-life eruption forced thousands to evacuate and destroyed buildings and farmland, yet thankfully led to no fatalities. This factual backdrop raises several questions about the plot's authenticity and representation.
While La Palma is not based on true events, it borrows elements from real-world scientific concerns. The island's geological history includes speculation about the potential for landslides causing devastating mega-tsunamis. A study dating back to 2001 suggested such waves could be generated if part of the Cumbre Vieja collapsed—though many experts, including the United States Geological Survey, argue this prospect remains highly unlikely.
Despite its scientific foundations, critics have pointed out how the narrative flirts with the fantastical. For example, proponents of the mega-tsunami theory have criticized the portrayal of swift events following the eruption as exaggerated and misleading. While viewers quickly embrace the drama, many question the fine line between raising awareness about natural disasters and sensationalizing them.
The theme resonates particularly with audiences living through eco-anxiety, as the show taps directly and alarmingly on fears of natural disasters amid climate change. During the series, we watch as characters face not only the immediate threats posed by the volcano but also navigate the societal chaos birthed under duress.
The emotional stakes are heightened as the Norwegian family encounters peril, adding layers to their survival story. It is this human struggle amid upheaval, more than the animated disasters, which keeps viewers engaged—if not entirely satisfied.
This trend of fictionalizing real-life disasters raises questions about the ethics of entertainment derived from trauma. On one hand, such shows could educate viewers on specific risks; on the other, they risk trivializing authentic fears and experiences.
La Palma provides visual splendor, using the stunning landscapes of the Canary Islands, including real filming locations. It aims to create tension, but as echoed through viewer critiques, not everyone finds the story credible.
The financial impact of La Palma could see overlapping effects for its namesake island; with the recent eruption fresh on minds and some potential tourists now wary due to the dramatized disaster, the reality of the show may intertwine dangerously with perceptions of safety and adventure.
Whether one appreciates the series for its creativity or denounces it for its artistic liberties, La Palma undeniably encapsulates the allure of disaster narratives. For now, it remains available for viewing globally on Netflix, generating views and divisive commentary from audiences.
