The Montreal Canadiens are reeling from the inconsistent performances of their forwards, particularly Kirby Dach, whose recent injury scare has raised concerns among fans and analysts alike. At just 23 years old and standing 6-foot-4, Dach has struggled to make his mark this season, experiencing both physical setbacks and performance challenges.
During a recent game, Dach was removed from play after taking a hard hit, leading to significant speculation about his health. According to Eric Engels, "It appears Kirby Dach was removed by the independent spotter. He took one shift after Samuelsson hit him, but still. He is in the Canadiens' locker room right now." His exit sparked worries not only about the immediate impact on the team but also about his long-term health as he recovers from prior injuries.
Stu Cowan noted the physical toll, stating, "It's no surprise, but Kirby Dach is now in the locker room. He took a very hard fall after being hit earlier in the period, which led to an interference penalty. He landed heavily on his shoulder, and it also seemed to affect his head." Fortunately, it was later reported Dach returned for the second period, leading many to suspect his absence was due to precautionary concussion protocols.
Despite returning to the ice, Dach’s performance this season has left much to be desired. He has recorded only 9 points over 30 games, including two goals, raising eyebrows as he has failed to capitalize on opportunities. Analysts have indicated this underperformance could stem from not being physically ready for the NHL season. Tony Marinaro remarked on BPM Sports, "Kirby Dach was not exactly the fittest guy on the team when camp started. And let’s say, it shows." This remark hints at Dach's earlier struggles with fitness following knee surgery, potentially inhibiting his full potential on the ice.
Adding to the discussion around Dach's performance, previous observations from Marinaro emphasized the broader disappointment surrounding him and teammate Juraj Slafkovsky. He expressed concern, stating, "Dach is currently playing like one of the worst players in the NHL! If it weren't for his name, he wouldn't even be in the Canadiens' lineup..." This stark assessment reflects the urgency with which the team and its fans are evaluating his contributions.
Performance metrics indicate Dach's struggle with penalties has also garnered criticism. Arpon Basu pointed out, "Three of Dach’s penalties were in the third period; the game was tied in two of those three instances." Dach’s undisciplined play not only places strain on the team but risks sidelining him to the press box if changes aren’t made quickly.
Fans and analysts alike have similarly highlighted how others on the team, such as Josh Anderson, provide models of effective play, contrasting their behaviors with Dach's current form. Basu noted, "It’s Josh Anderson who is actually at the very top in the NHL among forwards [in terms of penalties], but Anderson’s actions stem from working hard and trying to create something, whereas Dach is simply late and lacks the grit and intensity to explain Anderson’s penalties." This distinction emphasizes the expectation for Dach to adapt and improve swiftly.
The issue of injury continues to shadow Dach’s potential resurgence. Gilbert Delorme, the head coach, has openly confronted worries about Dach's fitness. While some believe he remains capable of flipping the narrative, the growing consensus urges caution. Tony Marinaro has suggested drastic measures, insisting Dach should be kept out of games to utilize players who may show more effort and determination, such as Michael Pezzetta. Marinaro stated, "If Martin St-Louis truly wants to wake up his troops, putting Dach as a healthy scratch would send the right message."
Looking forward, Dach and the Canadiens face multiple significant tests. Improved communication and team dynamics will be key as they navigate struggles on and off the ice. Fan engagement remains moderate, with supporters anxious to see how management responds to maintain team morale—and potentially Dach himself.
Overall, the Canadiens are set against the backdrop of mounting pressure as they evaluate Dach's role within the squad. The focus will be twofold: ensuring Dach’s health and performance improves, and reestablishing the quality expectations set at the season's start. The road to recovery may be long, but with sharp focus and determination, Dach could yet reclaim his position as one of the team's key forwards.
