In a significant shift for the New South Wales Police Force, Commissioner Karen Webb has announced her resignation, effective May 7, 2025. This decision comes after a tumultuous tenure marked by intense scrutiny and criticism, especially regarding her public performances and handling of high-profile incidents involving police conduct.
Appointed in February 2022, Webb made history as the first female police commissioner in the state. She expressed her deep honor in holding the position, stating, "My role as the first female police commissioner has been my greatest honour." However, her time in office has been overshadowed by challenges, including allegations of sexism and criticism regarding her media presence.
Webb's resignation follows months of speculation about her future, particularly after reports indicated that the Premier's office was distancing itself from her. Sources close to the situation suggested that Webb was encouraged to step down, a move that reflects ongoing tensions within the police force and its leadership. "For most of her 3.5 years as NSW Police Commissioner, Karen Webb hasn’t felt safe in the job," one insider noted.
In her resignation announcement, Webb highlighted the importance of allowing the government adequate time to appoint her successor, particularly with elections approaching in less than two years. She has recommended Deputy Commissioner Peter Thurtell to act in her role during the transition period. Webb plans to officially farewell the force at a ceremony in August 2025, coinciding with the next attestation at the Goulburn Police Academy.
The commissioner had intended to announce her retirement on May 18, 2025, to commemorate the anniversary of her own entry into the Goulburn Police Academy 38 years ago. However, news of her decision leaked prematurely, prompting a swift response from senior police and politicians.
Throughout her tenure, Webb faced significant challenges, including her response to the Bondi massacre and the deaths of civilians allegedly at the hands of police officers. The death of 95-year-old Clare Nowland, who was Tasered by a serving officer, drew intense public scrutiny, particularly after the police media office omitted critical details from initial reports. Webb was criticized for her delayed response to the media following these incidents.
Despite the controversies, Webb has left a lasting legacy within the NSW Police Force. Her initiatives included the establishment of the Domestic and Family Violence Registry, the Pulse program, and the creation of the Health Safety and Wellbeing Command, all aimed at improving the safety and wellbeing of both police officers and the communities they serve. NSW Police Minister Yasmin Catley praised Webb's contributions, stating, "I have nothing but heartfelt thanks for her incredible work and admiration for her many significant achievements."
Webb's departure raises questions about the future leadership of the police force, particularly with Deputy Commissioner Mal Lanyon being considered a strong contender for the role. Lanyon was among the final candidates when Webb was appointed, but concerns about past behavior had previously ruled him out. His recent tenure at the NSW Reconstruction Authority is seen as a strategic move amid ongoing speculation about his potential candidacy.
As the search for Webb's successor begins, the NSW Police Force faces the challenge of restoring public confidence and addressing the internal dynamics that have characterized its leadership in recent years. The upcoming changes may signal a new direction for the force, particularly as it continues to grapple with issues of accountability and transparency.
Webb's resignation marks a pivotal moment in the history of the NSW Police Force, highlighting both the challenges faced by women in leadership positions and the ongoing struggle for reform within the institution. As one senior officer remarked, "We eat our own, that’s for sure," reflecting the intense rivalries and pressures that have long been a part of the police culture.
In the wake of Webb's departure, the NSW Police Force must navigate the complexities of leadership transition while addressing the critical issues that affect its operations and public perception. The legacy of Karen Webb, both as a trailblazer and a controversial figure, will undoubtedly influence the future trajectory of policing in New South Wales.
