Broadway's latest offering, Just in Time, is a dazzling tribute to the late Bobby Darin, featuring the immensely talented Jonathan Groff in the lead role. The bio-musical, which opened on April 26, 2025, at Circle in the Square Theatre, has garnered critical acclaim for its vibrant portrayal of Darin's life, a journey that oscillates between soaring triumphs and profound struggles.
Jonathan Groff, a Tony Award winner known for his roles in Merrily We Roll Along and Hamilton, brings an electrifying energy to the stage as he embodies the legendary entertainer. Describing his character, Groff said, "He was at the height of his powers, when he was on the floor of a nightclub with the audience in the palm of his hand." This sentiment resonates throughout the performance, as Groff captures the essence of Darin's connection with his audience, a bond that he believes is vital in storytelling.
The production, developed and directed by Tony Award winner Alex Timbers, has been seven years in the making. It features a cast of 11 on-stage actors and a live band, bringing to life Darin's iconic hits, including “Beyond the Sea,” “Splish Splash,” “Dream Lover,” and “Mack the Knife.” The musical's book is crafted by Warren Leight and Isaac Oliver, with music supervision and arrangements by Andrew Resnick, ensuring that the sound is as captivating as the narrative.
Set against the backdrop of a lavish supper club, the show transports audiences to the vibrant nightlife of the late 1950s and early 1960s. Groff's performance is described as sensational, with critics noting his ability to convey deep emotion while delivering powerful vocals. The set design by Derek McLane and costume design by Catherine Zuber enhance the immersive experience, creating an atmosphere reminiscent of Darin's heyday.
Born Walden Robert Cassotto in 1936, Bobby Darin was a multifaceted performer—singer, dancer, musician, and Oscar nominee—who, until now, had never graced the Broadway stage. His career skyrocketed with the release of “Splish Splash” at just 22 years old, followed by the Grammy-winning “Mack the Knife,” which solidified his status as a pop sensation. The musical delves into Darin's life, including his marriage to actress Sandra Dee and the challenges he faced, such as his frail health stemming from childhood rheumatic fever.
Dodd Darin, Bobby's son, reflects on his father's legacy, stating, "It’s so beautiful that all these years later – he’s been gone over 50 years – we’re here talking about him. We’re remembering him.” Dodd's insights provide a personal touch to the narrative, as the show aims to honor Bobby's complex life while also addressing the darker aspects of his journey.
The portrayal of Darin's relationships, particularly with Sandra Dee, has sparked discussions among critics. While the show does not shy away from depicting the tumultuous nature of their marriage, some feel that it simplifies the complexities of their experiences. Critics have noted that Darin's narcissism, often attributed to his perfectionism, is framed in a way that seeks to soften his image.
Despite these critiques, Groff's performance remains a highlight, with many praising his ability to evoke empathy for Darin. His energetic stage presence and vocal prowess shine through, making it clear why he was chosen to portray such an iconic figure. As Darin himself once said, “A live audience was oxygen,” and Groff embodies that sentiment, igniting the stage with his passion.
As the show progresses, it explores Darin's evolution from a teen idol to a global sensation, highlighting the pressures of fame and the impact of his upbringing on his personal and professional life. The musical also touches on significant historical events, weaving them into the narrative to provide context to Darin's story.
The show’s opening numbers, including Steve Allen’s “This Could Be the Start of Something,” set a lively tone, but as the narrative deepens, it grapples with more serious themes. Critics have noted that while the musical begins with a vibrant floor show, it eventually shifts to a more somber exploration of Darin's life, particularly his struggles with identity and family secrets.
One poignant moment in the show reveals a long-held family secret that profoundly affected Darin's sense of self. Dodd Darin recalls the moment his father discovered that the woman he believed to be his sister was actually his mother, a revelation that left a lasting impact on Bobby. “He said that his whole life was a lie; he was, like, a fraud. It’s just devastating,” Dodd shared, highlighting the emotional weight that the show carries.
As Just in Time continues its run, it promises to be a memorable experience for audiences. With tickets now on sale through November 30, 2025, fans of Bobby Darin and musical theater alike have the opportunity to witness a captivating performance that honors the legacy of a true musical icon.
In a world where the stories of entertainers often fade into obscurity, Just in Time stands as a testament to Bobby Darin's enduring influence and the indelible mark he left on the world of music. As Groff takes the stage each night, he not only revives the spirit of Darin but also reminds us of the power of performance to connect and inspire.
