Jack Harrison’s loan spell at Everton has come under intense scrutiny as the winger struggles to find his footing this season, raising questions about his future with the club. The 28-year-old, who has yet to score or assist in 17 appearances this season, is facing criticism from fans and analysts alike, as Everton’s struggle for goals continues.
Everton's recent history has been tumultuous, marked by managerial changes and ownership shifts. Sean Dyche, taking charge at the club, has emphasized defensive solidity. Yet, the team aims to improve its fortunes as they approach their Boxing Day fixture against Manchester City. With just 14 goals scored over 16 matches, Dyche's side is under pressure to find the net more frequently to avoid relegation concerns.
Among the squad, Jack Harrison has emerged as one of the players with the most significant burden on his shoulders. After arriving on loan from Leeds United for the second consecutive season, expectations were high, particularly since his earlier tenure at Leeds saw him contribute meaningfully to their attacking play. Unfortunately, this time around, Harrison has found it difficult to replicate his past form. Following poor performances, including missing clear scoring opportunities against Chelsea, fans have begun to lose patience.
Yet, Dyche remains firmly in Harrison’s corner. He stated, "Jack Harrison has his question marks, he does an enormous shift. His tactical understandings are excellent. He’s up with the best." These comments suggest belief from the coaching staff, who understand the importance of Harrison’s versatility on the field—whether as a number ten or out wide. Dyche seems to think Harrison can be instrumental if he can overcome his current struggles.
Despite Dyche’s backing, many fans disagree. They argue Harrison’s output has not matched his effort, with only four goals and three assists during his time at Everton across two loan spells. This underperformance has fueled discussions about his potential return to Leeds United as the transfer window approaches. It’s clear there are reservations about another permanent deal, especially with the imminent restructuring of Everton’s squad post-takeover, led by The Friedkin Group.
Leeds United's supporters, meanwhile, have watched from the sidelines, almost expecting Harrison to return. With his new contract extending until 2028 signed last April, the clear sentiment was to part ways with Harrison through loans until he could either find his rhythm or become relevant again. Yet recent hints, such as reports indicating Everton may not be eager to send him back, complicate matters.
Complicatings Harrison's situation even more are rumors of planned changes within the Everton roster, potentially before January. With both the club’s performance and squad depth being evaluated critically, it seems unlikely Harrison’s loan will be ending prematurely. "There are some suggestions it could change under the new Everton ownership with plans for a January shake-up of the squad," insiders have noted, indicating forthcoming adjustments should they see fit. Nevertheless, Harrison’s lack of production could lead Everton to reconsider their options if his contribution doesn't improve significantly.
Beyond individual evaluation lies the bigger picture. Everton, with their recent change of ownership and structures, must also decide the fate of players who have not delivered. Indeed, if Harrison cannot demonstrate his value, it’s hard to foresee him signing permanently. Leeds United, now eyeing to return to the Premier League, might organize for Harrison’s return, depending on their status when the season ends. Potential deals could hinge on whether they secure promotion this season, leaving the door open for discussions about Harrison rejoining the squad.
Harrison's performances could shift rapidly with the right mental and tactical adjustments. The spotlight remains heavily on his shoulders, especially with Dyche advocating for him. The final months of the season will be decisive for the winger. Failure to produce at Everton may well bring the curtains down on what has been, so far, an unremarkable loan spell, sending him back to Leeds United to reassess his career moving forward.
With the pressure mounting and the potential for change looming on the horizon, Harrison stands at a crossroads. Fans and pundits alike will be watching closely to see whether he can turn his fortunes around before the window closes.
