Hearts vs St Johnstone promises to be a nail-biting encounter at Tynecastle Park as the two bottom-placed teams clash in what could be dubbed a relegation six-pointer. Facing off on December 22, 2024, both Heart of Midlothian and St Johnstone are acutely aware of the stakes involved; with neither side wanting to find itself adrift at the bottom of the Scottish Premiership as the holiday season approaches.
Hearts come limping to this fixture, sitting at the bottom of the table with just 13 points from 17 games. Their one win from the last five outings compounded with the recent exit from the Europa Conference League has left fans and pundits questioning the direction of the club. After their recent 2-2 draw against Moldovan side Petrocub—a match where they squandered opportunities to progress—restlessness is palpable among the fanbase.
The Gorgie Ultras, known for their passionate support, have chosen to boycott this match, leaving empty seats behind the goal at their usual place. This absence is not just about this match but more broadly reflects discontent with the club's performance and management. Given their strong record against St Johnstone—Hearts are unbeaten at home against them since 2019—there’s frustration from the fans who have seen potential slip through their fingers.
St Johnstone, currently sitting just above Hearts, with 14 points from 17 matches, are themselves struggling. Despite having impressive players like Benjamin Mbunga-Kimpioka, who stands out with six goals this season, they have failed to win any of their last five encounters with Hearts. Their last away match against Hearts culminated with them coming away empty-handed after losing 2-1. With only one win out of their last eight away matches—a meager victory against Dundee—confidence could be low for their visit to Edinburgh.
Under the management of Neil Critchley, Hearts are hoping to shake off their dire form and make the most of home advantage. The manager recently voiced the need for unity among players and fans alike, emphasizing, "We need the fans to be with us. They help us when they’re with us," according to midfielder Yan Dhanda. His statement highlights the importance of supporter backing during this tumultuous stretch.
The matchup is even more intriguing as Critchley and Valakari, the manager of St Johnstone, face off for the first time. Both are relatively new to their positions and come equipped with their own challenges, including injury lists and team morale. It is certainly going to be important for both managers to inspire their teams and navigate this high-pressure atmosphere.
Defensive frailties have plagued both clubs, with Hearts managing just one clean sheet from their last eight league matches. Despite their lack of goals, which has seen them fail to find the back of the net twice at home this season, Hearts maintain the capability to capitalize on St Johnstone’s vulnerable away record. The stakes could not be higher; three points would not only provide necessary relief but also significant momentum heading forward.
Key players will undoubtedly be under the spotlight during this tense encounter. For Hearts, Lawrence Shankland remains pivotal as he aims to add to his three league goals. His performance could spark the team, providing the spark needed to uplift the hearts of the home crowd. Conversely, on St Johnstone’s front, Mbunga-Kimpioka will be looked to for leadership and inspiration, especially considering he has managed to score consistently compared to his teammates.
It’s not just about the players on the pitch, but the atmosphere created by the fans off it. The Ultras’ absence speaks volumes about the discontent but also the stakes of the match. If Critchley’s men can create chances and secure the support they require, they might just turn their season around — after all, it only takes one good match to reignite hope.
Both teams approach this clash with heavy hearts and even heavier expectations. If there’s ever a moment for them to rise to the occasion, it’s now. Whether Hearts can shed their poor form and leverage home advantage or if St Johnstone can translate their weary legs and minds through gritty persistence remains to be seen. All eyes will be on Tynecastle as the whistle blows, launching what could be the most decisive showdown of the Premiership season so far.
