Controversy surrounding the Kickstarter campaign for the Good Omens graphic novel has reached new heights as the Terry Pratchett Estate has officially severed financial ties with co-creator Neil Gaiman. This decision follows multiple allegations of sexual abuse against Gaiman, who has denied the accusations. The fallout from these allegations prompted the estate to act decisively to maintain the integrity of the highly successful crowdfunding project.
Reported by Comic Book Resources, backers began requesting refunds shortly after the allegations surfaced. Initially, refund requests were locked in mid-November 2024 due to production processes. But according to updates on the Kickstarter page dated January 30, 2025, those requests can once again be submitted until February 7. The estate reassured backers, stating, "It has also been agreed, Neil Gaiman will not receive any proceeds from the graphic novel Kickstarter. Given the project management, production, and all communication has always been under the jurisdiction of the Estate on behalf of Good Omens at large, this will not fundamentally change the project itself."
Gaiman's association with the project has drawn scrutiny since the release of allegations detailed by former nanny Scarlett Pavlovich, who spoke to New York Magazine, describing disturbing instances of abuse. Amid these revelations, Dark Horse Comics, which published some of Gaiman’s previous works, acted swiftly by canceling plans for his adaptation of Anansi Boys. The decision was one of many actions reflecting the growing discomfort within the industry and the public surrounding Gaiman's work.
The crowdfunding campaign for the Good Omens graphic novel, adapted by Colleen Doran from the acclaimed book co-written by Gaiman and Pratchett, had made waves prior to these allegations, gathering over 36,000 backers and raising more than $3 million. The estate had assured supporters back then, saying they would manage the project and the financial elements directly.
On January 30, the estate shared via Kickstarter how the allegations have necessitated changes: "While we cannot speak any more on the subject at present, we have chosen to reopen a short refund window for those who would no longer like to support the graphic novel." The statement reflects the seriousness of the situation as more than nine women have come forward with allegations against Gaiman, increasing scrutiny not just from backers but also from the industry.
Gaiman himself released statements denying any wrongdoing yet admitting to some ambiguous situations. He mentioned they were consensual relationships, but critics argue the power dynamics involved could deem them predatory. Gaiman has been under fire for years due to instances reported by various news outlets, with the situation intensifying recently. The revelations have left backers and industry professionals concerned about Gaiman's role going forward.
The fallout extends beyond the immediate cancellation of Gaiman's projects. The ripple effects have raised questions about his past works, with DC Comics remaining uncharacteristically silent as well, even as discussions continue about the fate of reprints like The Sandman.
Despite the troubling revelations, Gaiman’s loyal fan base remains divided, with some expressing support for the other artists involved with the Good Omens project but others outright rejecting any works associated with him. The creative community watches closely as the Terry Pratchett Estate emphasizes its commitment to managing the project independently.
Looking forward, the estate has committed to running the Kickstarter campaign and PledgeManager independently of Neil Gaiman. They stress the graphic novel will remain true to its vision, enticing backers to stay engaged with the creative outcomes of artists involved without Gaiman's financial entanglement overshadowing their efforts.
Public response to the estate’s recent communications has leaned positively, with many backers expressing relief at the clarity provided and assurance they won't inadvertently support Gaiman through their contributions. The Pratchett Estate appears to be taking ethical steps not only to uphold the legacy of Terry Pratchett but to support the artistic integrity of all involved in the Good Omens adaptation.