In a thrilling match on March 20, 2025, Italy faced Germany in the first leg of the Nations League quarter-finals held at San Siro in Milan, ultimately succumbing to a final score of 1-2. Italy got off to a bright start, with midfielder Sandro Tonali scoring a stunning goal just nine minutes into the match, impressively capitalizing on a defensive error from Germany. However, as the game progressed, Germany's tactical adjustments and superior finishing turned the tide in their favor.
Early in the match, Italy's Tonali showcased his exceptional skill, scoring after a brilliant build-up involving several players. After receiving a perfectly weighted cross from Barella, Politano outpaced German defender Raum, delivering a low ball that was intercepted awkwardly by defender Tah. This error allowed Tonali to slot the ball home into an open net, much to the delight of the home crowd.
Despite their early advantage, Italy struggled to convert further chances, notably as Tonali later attempted a long-range shot that was well saved by German goalkeeper Baumann. Italy continued to press but failed to capitalize on their momentum. Following halftime, Germany made tactical substitutions, introducing Kleindiest, who quickly made an impact against a wavering Italian defense.
In the 49th minute, just after the restart, Germany equalized through Kleindiest, who nodded home a phenomenal cross from Kimmich, evading defensive marking from Italy’s Di Lorenzo and Bastoni. This might have been a wake-up call for the Italian side, but their inability to respond effectively led to further woes.
Despite several promising opportunities, including efforts from Kean and Raspadori, Italy could not find the back of the net. The turning point came in the 74th minute when Goretzka scored the winning goal for Germany. After a corner kick taken by Kimmich, Goretzka rose above his markers, directing a powerful header past vanquished goalkeeper Donnarumma.
Analyzing individual performances, Italy’s players received varied ratings, with Tonali earning praise and a high rating of 7.5 for his goal and overall contribution during the match. In contrast, goalkeeper Donnarumma, criticized for his positioning and inability to prevent Goretzka's header, only managed a rating of 5.5. Other notable performers included Politano, who received a rating of 6.5 for his involvement in the goal, while Barella was rated at 7 for his all-around play despite the result.
On the other side, German players also had standout moments, with Baumann receiving a rating of 7 for his key saves throughout the match, ensuring Italy's chances were kept at bay. Goretzka's overall presence in midfield was instrumental in Germany's comeback, leading to him also receiving a 7 rating. Kleindiest, a substitute, made a notable impact with a goal that contributed to the team’s win, also earning a rating of 7.
As the final whistle blew, the score reflected the home team's disappointment. Spalletti lamented the wasted opportunities and defensive lapses, emphasizing the need for improvement heading into the return leg in Dortmund. "We should have been more ruthless in front of goal," he stated, echoing the sentiments shared by players and supporters alike.
Looking ahead, Italy faces a tough challenge in the second leg where they will need to overturn the deficit and secure a win to progress further in the Nations League. The head coach Spalletti will likely be focusing on tightening up the defense while encouraging his players to seize every scoring opportunity.
The upcoming match will certainly be crucial for the Italian side, who will need a significant turnaround to keep their hopes alive for the Finals Four. Fans and analysts alike will be tuned in to see if the Azzurri can rise to the occasion.
