Dorthy Moxley, the mother who dedicated much of her life to seeking justice for her daughter Martha Moxley, has passed away at the age of 92. Her death marks the end of a poignant chapter in a murder case filled with legal intrigue and emotional turmoil. Dorthy Moxley died at her home in Summit, New Jersey, from complications arising from the flu and possibly pneumonia, as reported by her son John Moxley.
For decades, Dorthy was the unwavering face of the fight for justice following the tragic murder of her 15-year-old daughter, who was brutally attacked on October 30, 1975. Her body was discovered the following day, hidden under a tree on the family estate located in the affluent neighborhood of Belle Haven, Greenwich, Connecticut. The notorious nature of Martha’s murder, combined with its unsolved status for many years, made it one of Connecticut's most infamous cases, drawing national attention and inspiring countless discussions, books, and documentaries.
Throughout her life, Dorthy turned her heartbreak over the loss of her daughter—who was bludgeoned to death with a golf club—into unwavering activism. Michael Skakel, the Kennedy family cousin suspected of the murder, was arrested years after the crime, with charges stemming from evidence indicating he was the last person seen with Martha on the night of her murder.
John Moxley reflected on his mother’s spirit, stating, “Through all the ups and downs, she was the most glass-half-full person I’ve ever known.” A staunch advocate, Dorthy maintained her belief in Skakel's guilt throughout the extensive legal battles, which saw him convicted of murder in 2002 before having his conviction vacated on grounds of inadequate representation by his original lawyer.
The twists and turns of the case only deepened Dorthy’s resolve. After Skakel was released on bail following the overturning of his conviction, she continued to raise awareness about the case. Her son noted, “My mother was always grateful and chose to focus on the communal spirit, if you will, rather than the law.” The family believed deeply in their conviction of Skakel's guilt, though they found some peace with the idea of not pursuing another trial.
Throughout her years of activism, Dorthy not only focused on her daughter's case but also sought to support other families grappling with similar tragedies. John Moxley recalled Dorthy being invited by police departments to meet with other victims' family members who felt uncomfortable discussing their experiences with law enforcement. He described her as “kind and cooperative,” someone who used her own experience to help others navigate the challenges of similar situations.
Dorthy's efforts and those of her supporters, including the media’s intense scrutiny of the case, kept Martha's murder from fading away as just another cold case. She frequently made appearances on television, bringing her daughter’s case back to the forefront, as many involved became aware of the emotional toll the decades-long fight had inflicted on her.
Even during times of deep despair, Dorthy Moxley remained positive. She often expressed belief not only in justice but also in the goodness of people, remarking once, “I believe in angels,” reflecting her hopefulness amid the trauma. John Moxley mentioned, “Somebody one time she was tough. She said, ‘I’m not tough. I’m just strong.’”
While Michael Skakel’s legal battles seemed to overshadow the quest for truth, Dorthy’s persistence ensured Martha’s memory and story continued to resonate with the public. The highs and lows of the case—highlighted by Skakel’s release and the state's decision not to retry him—did not deter her conviction. Years later, she still firmly believed, “He’s guilty,” making clear her thoughts on the entire situation, even as time wore on.
The Moxley family continues to grapple with the loss and the complexity of seeking justice within the U.S. legal system, often imbued with connections and heavy influences. Dorthy’s passing brings closure to her personal quest but raises questions about how true justice can be achieved and how the legacy of her fight will continue to inform advocacy for victims.
The tributes flowing from the community after her death reflect the impact she had. With her unmistakable tenacity, Dorthy Moxley showed many how to turn tragedy and loss not only toward personal healing but also toward broader support for justice and celebration of those lost.
The death of Dorthy Moxley leads to deeply felt mourning but also to renewed conversations surrounding victims' rights, advocacy, and, most poignantly, the enduring memory of her daughter Martha and the unresolved nature of her case. Dorthy's remarkable spirit and dedication to justice will undoubtedly inspire future generations to stand up for the rights of murder victims and their families.
