Disney's upcoming remake of the beloved classic "Snow White" ("Schneewittchen") has stirred quite the controversy as its release date approaches. Scheduled to hit German cinemas on March 20, 2025, the film, which has been highly anticipated since its announcement, is facing multifaceted debates over its casting choices and shifts from the original story, challenging traditional views on storytelling.
The 2025 film adaptation features Rachel Zegler, who plays the titular role of Snow White, and Gal Gadot as the evil stepmother. Zegler, who has Colombian and Polish roots, was met with backlash, particularly from conservative commentators who criticized her casting as emblematic of "wokeness". Some accused Disney of straying from the traditional portrayal of Snow White, who is often depicted as "white as snow". The actress herself addressed this issue directly, stating, "Während ich Schneewittchen spiele, repräsentiere ich nicht nur die Figur, sondern auch das Bewusstsein, dass Vielfalt unsere Geschichten bereichern sollte."
Adding to the film's tension, Zegler did not shy away from voicing her criticism of some aspects of the original fairy tale. She deemed the narrative as "outdated," especially the portrayal of the love story revolving around the prince, whom she described as "stalking" Snow White. "Schneewittchen wird nicht vom Prinzen gerettet werden, und sie träumt nicht von wahrer Liebe, sondern davon, die Anführerin zu werden, von der sie weiß, dass sie es sein kann," she explained, highlighting the film's emphasis on empowerment over traditional romance.
On the other hand, Gadot's involvement has incited its own controversies, primarily due to her political stance on the Israel-Palestine conflict. She has vocally opposed antisemitism and supported the release of hostages taken by Hamas, which has prompted backlash from those aware of her ties to the Israeli military and Zegler's pro-Palestinian activism. This difference led to speculations of tension on set. Yet, according to insiders, Gadot and Zegler maintained professional relations during filming, differing views notwithstanding.
The premiere of the film on March 15, 2025, came amid heightened awareness surrounding its casting debates, with Disney taking unusual steps to mitigate press interactions. The red carpet event was noticeably subdued, forbidding interviews with the stars and reducing media frenzy around them, potentially to sidestep drama and keep focus on the film's artistic merits.
Despite the controversies, the initial reactions from film critics and influencers have been surprisingly positive. Many have praised Zegler's performance, calling her portrayal of Snow White enchanting and noting the film's impressive visuals and musicality. Entertainment critiques highlight the refreshing depth infused through Wilson's script, making the story relevant for today's audiences. According to Ash Crossan, "Die Botschaft kommt gut rüber, die Tiere sind bezaubernd, und Rachel Zegler sowie ihre faszinierende Stimme sind atemberaubend." Katcy Stephan from Variety commented, "Rachel Zegler ist eine strahlende Supernova in 'Schneewittchen' und verkörpert auf wunderschöne Weise die anmutige, sanfte Natur der originalen Disney-Prinzessin.", indicating a positive reception for its unique reinterpretation.
Moving forward, Disney is hopeful the film will resonate with contemporary viewers, bridging the past with modern ideals without losing its traditional charm. While critics like Peter Dinklage have dissected narrative elements, particularly critiquing the portrayal of dwarves as "backward," Disney has reassured audiences of its commitment to respectful representation going forward, stating there would be no little people portraying the dwarves this time, aiming to eliminate negative stereotypes from earlier versions.
The buzz surrounding this remake reflects not only the power of nostalgia but also the necessity for shifts within classic storytelling paradigms. With Zegler stepping forward as a role model for diverse representation, "Schneewittchen" aims to craft its own legacy, one revitalized for the present day. Disney has invested over $200 million, showcasing its belief in this ambitious project, with the hopes to win over both traditionalists and progressive audiences.
Though controversies during pre-release might suggest turbulent waters for "Schneewittchen," the film seems poised to invite discussions about representation and modernization. Disney’s latest endeavor, originating from the 1937 classic, marks another chapter not just for its history but potentially for the evolution of fairy tales adapted for the silver screen, as we await March 20, 2025.
