During the recent Premier League clash on January 5, 2025, between Liverpool and Manchester United, Matthijs de Ligt found himself at the center of controversy after conceding a penalty due to handball. The incident unfolded as the match, held at Anfield, showcased high stakes for both teams: Liverpool aimed to solidify its position at the top of the league, and Manchester United sought to recover from a poor season.
The drama began when de Ligt’s arm was raised during play, leading to contact with the ball after Alexis Mac Allister aimed his header toward goal. Although referee Michael Oliver initially decided against awarding the penalty, VAR intervened, advising him to review the incident on the monitor. Upon re-examination, Oliver changed his decision, awarding Liverpool a penalty kick. Mo Salah stepped up and scored, temporarily putting Liverpool ahead at 2-1.
This penalty decision prompted significant scrutiny from football commentators. Gary Neville, who provided analysis for Sky Sports, openly questioned de Ligt's decision-making, stating, "I think he could be in trouble... When your arm's high like... you’re asking for big trouble." He expressed disbelief over why the defender would position his arm so high during such pivotal moments of the match.
Contributing to the conversation was Jamie Carragher, another voice on Sky Sports, who remarked, "He’s actually turning away," emphasizing the complexity of the decision to penalize de Ligt when he was seemingly attempting to avoid the ball. This commentary underscored the tension and uncertainty surrounding the interpretation of the rules, especially with VAR playing such a central role.
Further discussion arose from previous performances by de Ligt this season. Fans took to social media, expressing their frustrations and disappointment. One fan candidly tweeted, "De Ligt single handedly threw the game away... this is the worst defender I’ve ever seen," reflecting widespread discontent with his performance. Many voiced concerns about his capability to handle high-pressure situations, leading to calls for his replacement by promising youngsters in the team.
Pat Nevin, formerly of Chelsea and now providing insight for BBC Radio 5 Live, backed the penalty decision, stating, "I would give...that as a penalty every day of the week," noting the unnatural position of de Ligt's arm. He remarked, "His hand was so high, right above his head," indicating the growing consensus among pundits and former professionals on the validity of the call.
While Liverpool celebrated the goal, Manchester United fought back and equalized through Amad Diallo late in the match, resulting in the game ending 2-2. United's fight back left them still struggling mid-table, highlighting their inconsistent season.
The fallout from the incident exposed the growing frustrations of fans and analysts toward Matthijs de Ligt’s performances since his arrival at Old Trafford. Despite having been brought to the club for €45 million following Erik ten Hag's tenure at Ajax, de Ligt's time at Manchester United has not been smooth. Criticism has mounted over his defensive lapses, with many supporters calling for manager Ruben Amorim to reconsider his position on the starting lineup.
A wide array of fan reactions flooded social media after the match. Many called de Ligt "embarrassing" and “a disgrace.” His performance at Anfield was viewed not just as another error, but as part of a troubling trend; critics cited previous instances where he faltered defensively, including earlier this season against West Ham.
De Ligt's recent form places him under immense pressure as expectations rise for Manchester United to rebuild after years of uneven performances. The match against Liverpool was another chapter of scrutiny for the Dutch international, leaving fans to wonder if he could rise to the occasion or if he would remain mired in controversy.
With the penalty decision illustrating the pivotal role VAR plays in today’s football, and de Ligt’s handball becoming part of larger discussions on player accountability, the incident stands as a reminder of the fine line players walk during high-stakes matches. His actions and the response to them will undoubtedly linger as United navigates this challenging season.
United fans now face yet another tumultuous transfer window, with cries for more reinforcements echoing throughout the club, high hopes pinned on future performances to EXORCISE these disappointing moments and reclaim the pride of Manchester United.