David Fincher is set to direct a sequel to Quentin Tarantino’s acclaimed film, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, with Brad Pitt reprising his role as the charismatic stuntman Cliff Booth. This exciting project, which is reported to be a derivative rather than a direct sequel, is being produced by Netflix and is set to begin filming in the summer of 2025.
The announcement has generated a mix of anticipation and skepticism, particularly given Tarantino’s distinctive style and his previous criticisms of streaming platforms. While Tarantino is on board to write the script, the decision to hand over directorial duties to Fincher has left some fans questioning whether the sequel can capture the original's unique vibe.
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, released in 2019, grossed an impressive $392.1 million worldwide, showcasing the chemistry between Pitt and Leonardo DiCaprio, who played fading TV star Rick Dalton. The film was not only a tribute to the golden age of Hollywood but also a reflection of the changing landscape of the film industry, intertwined with the infamous Manson family murders.
Interestingly, the sequel's script is believed to be a reworked version of Tarantino’s previously shelved project, The Movie Critic, which was intended to be his tenth and final film. This project was set in 1977 Los Angeles and focused on a cynical film reviewer for a pornography magazine. Tarantino had scrapped The Movie Critic in April 2024, stating he had a change of heart about it being his last film.
Despite concerns over the shift in direction, Fincher brings a wealth of experience to the table. Known for his meticulous approach in films like Se7en and The Social Network, he has a strong working relationship with Pitt, having collaborated on several projects including Fight Club and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. However, Fincher's style is markedly different from Tarantino's, which raises questions about how well he can adapt to the laidback, humorous tone that defined the original.
According to sources, the sequel is expected to have a budget of around $200 million, with Tarantino reportedly receiving $20 million for his screenplay. There are also rumors that DiCaprio may make a cameo appearance, although his involvement has not been confirmed.
Fans of the original film have expressed mixed feelings about the sequel. Some are excited to see Pitt return to a role that earned him an Oscar, while others feel that the absence of Tarantino behind the camera might dilute the film's essence. Tarantino’s unique voice and vision were integral to the success of the first film, and many hope that his script will still allow the sequel to resonate with audiences.
Fincher’s style is often characterized by dark themes and psychological depth, which contrasts sharply with the comedic undertones of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. While he has shown versatility in his career, the challenge lies in balancing the lightheartedness of Tarantino’s script with his own darker sensibilities. The original film’s charm came from its relaxed, almost nostalgic atmosphere, which may be difficult to replicate under Fincher’s direction.
Moreover, there are logistical challenges to consider. Tarantino owns the rights to the characters from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, while Sony retains the rights to the original film. This legal nuance means that Fincher’s project cannot be labeled a straightforward sequel, but rather a film that utilizes the same characters and is inspired by Tarantino’s work.
As fans await more details about the project, the collaboration between Tarantino and Fincher is certainly intriguing. Both directors have made significant contributions to cinema, albeit in very different ways. Tarantino’s flair for dialogue and character development contrasts with Fincher’s technical precision and suspenseful storytelling.
While the film is still in its early stages, the involvement of both filmmakers promises a unique cinematic experience. With a mix of nostalgia and fresh perspectives, the sequel could potentially explore new dimensions of Cliff Booth’s character and the Hollywood landscape he inhabits.
As the film gears up for production, the anticipation continues to build. Will Fincher be able to honor the legacy of Tarantino’s original vision while bringing his own style to the table? Only time will tell. For now, fans can look forward to seeing Pitt back in action as Cliff Booth, navigating the complexities of a Hollywood that continues to evolve.
In the end, the collaboration between Tarantino and Fincher might just yield a film that honors the spirit of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood while paving the way for a new narrative. Whether this sequel will capture the hearts of audiences or become a mere footnote in the cinematic landscape remains to be seen.
