The controversy surrounding the closure of the French television channel C8 has sparked significant public outcry, particularly from its most recognizable host, Cyril Hanouna. Following Emmanuel Macron's remarks during the Salon de l’Agriculture, Hanouna has made headlines with his explosive reaction, criticizing the president and raising questions about the political motivations behind the decision to shut down the channel.
On February 24, 2025, Hanouna aired his grievances during his widely watched show, Touche pas à mon poste (TPMP), where he expressed his disappointment over the loss of C8’s frequency. "Emmanuel Macron dit n’importe quoi," Hanouna declared, emphasizing his displeasure with the national discourse surrounding the issue. His sentiment reflects the frustrations of many associated with the network, particularly employees faced with unemployment due to the ARCOM's decision not to renew the station's license.
Many have interpreted Macron's comments as dismissive, particularly when he suggested during the salon, "Ça n’est pas une décision politique. La loi a été conçue pour que ce ne soit pas une décision politique." This statement, meant to defuse claims of political bias, was met with skepticism by Hanouna and his audience, who believe the closure was influenced by pressure from left-wing factions.
José, one of Hanouna’s listeners, did not hold back during the discussion. "Emmanuel Macron n’a pas eu les co*lles. Il n’a pas le courage," he said, echoing sentiments of disdain for the president's handling of the situation. It was clear from the reaction on-air and online just how deeply this closure affects both the network's staff and its fans, who view Hanouna as both a host and defender of their interests.
Hanouna's criticism was sharp, focusing on the practical realities of the situation, particularly the claim made by Macron about employment for C8 staff elsewhere. "Il dit qu’ils vont retrouver du travail dans les deux nouvelles chaînes. Ils sont à 4 euros de budget et ils vont payer 400 personnes. Il faut arrêter de se moquer du monde," Hanouna asserted, pointing out the improbability of this scenario. A report by Checknews suggests the number of jobs available has been significantly inflated, raising concerns about the integrity of the administration's claims.
Gauthier Le Bret, another panelist on TPMP, offered additional critique by stating, "Il y a plusieurs volets politiques à cette décision," indicating the multifaceted political dimensions affecting C8. He suggested Macron's lack of intervention demonstrates political cowardice, questioning whether the president truly values freedom of expression if he allows a broadcaster like C8 to face such harsh consequences.
During the heated discussion, Hanouna found himself attempting to navigate the intensity of the listeners' frustrations. "Il est chaud José," he noted, showing some concern for the heightened emotions involved. Nevertheless, it was evident he welcomed the passionate discourse, fueling the show's already vibrant atmosphere.
The cancellation of C8 has ignited concerns among viewers and media professionals alike, with many arguing it symbolizes the broader threat to media plurality and freedom of speech. Criticism of ARCOM has mounted, with various commentators and listeners like Véronique arguing, "C’est une honte l'Arcom, qu'on ferme cette commission," clearly indicating dissatisfaction with the regulatory body and its motives.
This situation also raises questions about the political ramifications for Hanouna himself. Some speculate whether his fiery comments could position him as a future political contender, especially as public opinions on media freedom grow more polarized. Given the scrutiny he is now under, it may be pivotal for Hanouna to articulate his future plans as C8 prepares to go off air.
Despite the presumptive conclusions Macron seems to draw about the closure's motivations, Hanouna’s passion for defending C8 remains strong. His assertion, “sachez qu’on va avoir les images des caméras. On les aura peut-être demain. Ça va secouer,” suggests he intends to confront the issue head-on, implying new revelations may surface soon.
Whether or not this leads to significant political change or simply serves as fodder for entertainment remains to be seen. For now, the spotlight is on the impending closure of C8, and on Cyril Hanouna, who continues to navigate this storm with all the conviction of someone who has made the world of entertainment his battleground.