Carter Starocci of Penn State has etched his name into the history books, becoming the first wrestler ever to win five NCAA titles. The milestone came on Saturday night, March 22, 2025, at the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, where Starocci faced Northern Iowa’s Parker Keckeisen in a thrilling match that concluded with a score of 4-3.
Starocci’s victory was not merely a personal achievement; it was an event that echoed through the annals of college wrestling history. The match played out like a chess game between two titans, and as the clock ticked down in the third period, the score remained knotted at 1-1. With just 48 seconds left, Starocci countered a shot from Keckeisen, executing a flawless takedown that secured his fifth championship title.
Before this historic win, Starocci’s career had been already remarkable. He first captured a title in 2021 as a freshman, defeating Michael Kemerer in an intense overtime bout. The following year, he continued his winning streak, prevailing over Mekhi Lewis in a two-tiebreaker match. His 2023 season saw him dominate Mike Labriola, pinning him in the first period. In 2024, he became the sixth wrestler ever to win four NCAA titles, finishing his tournament with three shutout victories, all while nursing a heavily braced right knee.
Moving up a weight class to 184 pounds this season presented new challenges. Starocci previously faced Keckeisen at the NWCA All-Star Classic in November 2024, where he edged out a 4-1 decision in a bloody overtime match. Reflecting on that encounter, Starocci noted, "I think that's one of the blessings of going to Penn State University... We have almost every single look in the room possible." His training under renowned coach Cael Sanderson undoubtedly played an integral role in his success.
As Starocci concluded his phenomenal college wrestling career, he carried a stellar record of 104-4, with a perfect 26-0 in his final season. Yet, when asked about his latest victory and all that it entails, he remained remarkably humble. He stated, "For me, it means nothing... It’s here tomorrow, then it’s gone the next day, and then it’s about the next group and the next group." Starocci expressed his belief that the true measure of success lies beyond accolades, saying, "You can take the Penn State wrestling championship logo away... and for me, that’s why I do it."
The victory not only solidified Starocci's legacy but also contributed to a record-setting team performance. With this championship win, he helped the Penn State Nittany Lions score a total of 173 points, breaking the previous team record of 172.5 points set by Iowa in 1997. Starocci’s points were crucial as the Nittany Lions eye further success with teammates Mitchell Mesenbrink and Josh Barr also competing for titles.
Despite the magnitude of the moment, Starocci maintained a sense of perspective. He humorously critiqued ESPN’s decision to have the finals lead off with his match, reflecting, "You've got a guy going for his fifth title, and you have the reigning champ. I think whoever wins that match is the Hodge Trophy winner. It just makes me laugh... it's no surprise on why wrestling isn't mainstream." It was a reminder that while individual achievements are celebrated, the sport itself has room to grow in popularity.
As the crowd erupted in applause following his historic bout, Starocci's mind was already shifting toward the future. He understood the significance of his achievement but emphasized that sustainability in accomplishments and legacies rely on what one does next. He noted, "I think something like five national titles, I feel something like that comes and goes." His thoughts lingered not just on personal glory, but on the promotion and growth of wrestling as a whole.
Carter Starocci’s journey has been one of perseverance, exceptional talent, and an unyielding desire to excel, qualities that have undeniably left an indelible mark on NCAA wrestling. He stands as a beacon for future generations of wrestlers, embodying dedication and determination. The wrestling community anticipates what’s next for this extraordinary athlete as he transitions to life beyond the mat, where his lessons and experiences will surely continue to inspire.
