With the highly anticipated release of Captain America: Brave New World just around the corner, fans and critics alike are buzzing with opinions about Anthony Mackie's debut as the titular hero. Set to hit theaters on February 14, 2025, this fourth entry in the beloved franchise marks Mackie's first solo outing as Captain America, following his role as Falcon, and is under the scrutiny of audiences eager to see how the character has evolved.
Initial reviews paint the film as uneven, with some praising its action but criticizing the overall execution. The reviews suggest Brave New World struggles to deliver the depth and excitement previous installments offered. Critics have pointed out the movie feels disjointed and poorly paced, with some labeling it as 'a safe, forgettable rehash' of earlier installments. According to Mikey Walsh from Nerdist, 'the uneven and disappointing Disney+ series The Falcon and the Winter Soldier was a more successful showcase for both actor and character than Brave New World.
Screenwriter Malcolm Spellman, known for his work on the aforementioned series, is seen as repeating themes previously explored without adding anything original. Walsh emphasized the film suffers from it’s dialogue, which he describes as some of the worst in MCU history. He noted, 'Much of the film feels like someone tried to write Aaron Sorkin-esque quick banter without ever having actually seen anything Sorkin has done. It’s rarely funny or witty but often awkward.'
Despite its shortcomings, fans can expect thrilling action sequences, as the movie reportedly contains two major set pieces, including spectacular aerial battles featuring Sam Wilson and his partner, Joaquin Torres, played by Danny Ramirez. Walsh wrote, 'The big Captain America/Red Hulk showdown is also very entertaining,' noting the impressive CGI and execution of these action scenes.
On the flip side, another review highlights how this iteration of Captain America feels more earthbound than its predecessors. Critics have noted how Wilson lacks the serum-enhanced invincibility of his predecessor, Chris Evans’s Steve Rogers, giving him perhaps a more relatable but less powerful portrayal. According to Variety, Wilson’s heroism now seems more reliant on his vibranium shield and wingsuit than ever before.
Harrison Ford's performance as President Thaddeus 'Thunderbolt' Ross has also garnered attention. Critics praise Ford’s nuanced interpretation of the role, which introduces complexity as he navigates between the pillars of government authority and personal tumult. This dynamic adds to the film’s attempt at exploring some darker themes, reflecting on modern political climates. According to Ford, the film aims to provide 'an escape from reality' rather than dwell on direct commentaries of current political figures.
Another review noted how Brave New World fails to successfully integrate the serious ramifications of its plot—San Wilson’s progression as Captain America juxtaposed against the political turmoil introduced by President Ross. Despite having potential for commentary on race and the administration as represented by Ross, some critics feel the movie shies away from truly engaging with these complex issues.
Reviewers have also expressed concerns over the film’s reliance on visual effects rather than compelling storytelling. A critic noted, 'The movie feels like it was made by focus groups.' The bland execution of some action sequences and the underwhelming character arcs were cited as factors contributing to the film’s perceived failure to stand out within the Marvel canon.
Yet, amid criticisms, there are glimpses of hope, particularly concerning character interactions. Audiences will enjoy Mackie's portrayal of Wilson, bringing warmth and relatability to the character. Critics have observed consistently engaging performances from the supporting cast, with Danny Ramirez being highlighted for his charisma as the new Falcon.
Overall, Captain America: Brave New World encapsulates the current sentiment among Marvel fans: cautious optimism. While it's clear the film has its flaws, its arrival after several months of Marvel inactivity rekindles interest and debate about the direction of the MCU. Still, the looming question remains: can Mackie's Captain America transcend the barriers set by previous films, or will it become yet another example of superhero fatigue within Hollywood?