The Montreal Canadiens are gearing up for a pivotal offseason following their recent elimination from the playoffs in the first round. With the NHL Draft Lottery now complete, the Canadiens have secured back-to-back picks at 16 and 17 in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft. This unique position presents general manager Kent Hughes and his team with a significant decision: should they keep both selections, trade up for a higher pick, or leverage one of their first-rounders to acquire immediate help for their roster?
Option one is to retain both picks and add two promising prospects to their already robust pipeline. While selections 16 and 17 don't guarantee the acquisition of future NHL stars, history shows that impactful players can emerge from this range. The Canadiens have developed a strong system, making this draft class an enticing opportunity for potential additions.
Among the prospects generating buzz is Kashawn Aitcheson, a talented offensive defenceman known for his elite skills and powerful shot. Aitcheson has seen his stock rise sharply as the draft approaches, and he could provide the Canadiens with another offensive weapon to nurture. Another potential target is Logan Hensler, a mobile two-way defenceman expected to develop into a reliable top-four blueliner. His skating ability and calmness under pressure make him a perfect fit for the modern NHL.
Additionally, the Canadiens could consider Justin Carboneau, a forward with a high hockey IQ who could enhance their depth. If Montreal opts to keep both picks, they could secure a strong combination of a forward and a defenceman or perhaps two forwards that would significantly bolster their future middle-six.
The second option on the table is to trade up into the top 10 by bundling their two first-round picks. This strategy would likely require the Canadiens to part with one of their two second-round picks as well. Moving up could enable them to select a player with a higher upside, aligning with their rebuild goals.
Hughes has worked diligently to accumulate draft capital over the past few years, and with a prospect pool that includes talents like Lane Hutson, David Reinbacher, and Jacob Fowler, the team has the depth needed to make a move without jeopardizing their future.
However, trading up comes with its own set of risks. The higher the pick, the greater the expectations, and if the scouting staff has a specific player in mind—someone they view as a cornerstone for the franchise—it may be worth the cost to secure that player.
The final option is a more aggressive approach: trading one of their first-round picks to fill a current roster need, particularly at the second-line center position. While Nick Suzuki leads the top line, the Canadiens have struggled to find consistent production in the second line. By packaging one of their first-round picks with a roster player or a prospect, they could potentially acquire an established top-six center.
As Hughes has emphasized in the past, the objective is not merely to gather prospects but to build a competitive team. With the Canadiens showing signs of progress and nearing the completion of their rebuild, this summer could be the ideal time to add a proven NHL player to their ranks.
Using either pick 16 or 17 as a trade asset provides Montreal with leverage in negotiations. This strategy could accelerate their timeline and enhance their competitiveness in the Eastern Conference, easing the burden on their young core by providing veteran support.
Nevertheless, trading a first-round pick is a calculated gamble. The return must be immediate and impactful to justify passing on a promising young player. The Canadiens stand at a crucial juncture in their rebuild. With picks 16 and 17 in a deep 2025 Draft, they possess valuable assets. Whether Hughes and his team choose to stockpile young talent, pursue an aggressive move up the draft board, or swing a trade to improve the current roster, the decisions made this summer will resonate for years to come.
As the draft approaches, the excitement builds not just for the Canadiens but for all teams involved. The NHL Entry Draft is a vital event for franchises looking to secure their futures. Each selection carries the weight of potential, and for teams like Montreal, the stakes are particularly high.
In conclusion, the Canadiens hold a pivotal position in the upcoming draft, and the choices they make will shape not only their immediate future but also their long-term trajectory. The decisions made in the coming weeks will be critical for a franchise eager to return to its former glory.
