The BYU Cougars delivered an impressive performance on December 28, 2024, as they decisively defeated the Colorado Buffaloes 36-14 at the Alamodome in San Antonio, Texas, marking one of the most significant victories under head coach Kalani Sitake.
This matchup was highly anticipated, not just for the rivalry between these two Big 12 members, but also because of the notable star power on the Colorado side, including quarterback Shedeur Sanders and Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter. Yet, it was BYU's defense and dynamic special teams play which proved to be the difference.
From the first kickoff, it became evident BYU was ready to make a statement. Coach Kalani Sitake had made it clear during the week leading up to the game he was eager to showcase his players, stating, "I can't wait to 'unleash' them" at the Pep Rally. He certainly did just as the Cougars executed their game plan to perfection.
BYU’s defense stifled Colorado’s high-powered offense, effectively containing Sanders, who managed just 70 yards passing at halftime. Their defensive strategy focused on limiting the impact of Hunter, who caught only two passes for 101 yards, showcasing BYU’s capability to control elite talents.
Though the Cougars started slowly, scoring just ten points halfway through the second quarter, things shifted swiftly with special teams making pivotal plays. BYU punt returner Parker Kingston returned one punt for 64 yards, which established momentum and extended the lead to 17-0. Overall, Kingston helped anchor the special teams, accumulating over 100 yards against the Buffaloes.
BYU effectively established dominance with exceptional physicality from the outset. The players sent physical messages on every play, which was symptomatic of their aggressive strategy. Sitake emphasized the importance of setting the tone, and his team delivered, underlining the need for toughness and resilience as they went toe-to-toe with Colorado.
Following Kingston's momentum charge, BYU quarterback Jake Retzlaff showcased his capability, completing 12 of 21 passes for 151 yards, admittedly with two interceptions. His performance did not impress everyone, but the contributions from his teammates, particularly running back LJ Martin, were particularly noteworthy. Martin carried the ball 16 times, accumulating 88 yards and finding the end zone twice, including one touchdown run where he dragged multiple defenders across the goal line, pushing the Cougars to a 33-7 lead late in the third quarter.
The BYU coaching staff, particularly offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick and defensive coordinator Jay Hill, also received high praise for their effective game strategies. Roderick executed creative plays, effectively utilizing QB runs which caught Colorado's defense off guard. Hill’s defensive game plan kept the quarterback under pressure, leading to three sacks and forcing Sanders to make hurried throws.
Coach Sanders, emotionally reflective before the game, understood the stakes of this final contest, stating, "We were supposed to be in the crib right now, focused on recruiting, improving our rosters. Nevertheless, we're here." His team, packed with promise and potential, could not execute as planned due to BYU’s stout defense. The Buffaloes had spells of effective plays but not enough to capitalize significantly, leaving fans both excited and frustrated.
Although the game didn’t end the way the Buffaloes wanted, Coach Sanders takes comfort knowing both his star players, Sanders and Hunter, are likely headed to the NFL draft, leaving behind strong legacies at Colorado. The Buffaloes had good moments, but BYU’s comprehensive game plan proved particularly effective, marking the Cougars' first victory over any team featuring a Heisman winner.
Speaking of victories, the magnitude of this win should not be underestimated as it sets the stage for BYU’s ambitions for the 2025 season. With their standout performance, especially after such close losses earlier this season, they are poised to gain more national traction. Indeed, play-by-play announcer Dave Pasch confidently noted Retzlaff's potential to be among the top five quarterbacks next season.
This Alamo Bowl victory also alleviates some pressures surrounding Sitake’s tenure. BYU ends the season on high, making for a feel-good storyline heading forward, which even Coach Sitake admitted was one of his favorites to date.
The matchup concluded with BYU accumulating 331 total yards and dominating time of possession. They executed on both ends of the field, reflecting the hard work and preparation put forth throughout the season. For Cougars fans, this emphatic bowl victory has reignited hopes and expectations for the coming years.
With the bowl wrapping up, fans are already excited about what the future holds for their teams. While BYU looks to build on this success, Colorado's star players will soon be taking the next step toward their NFL future. One thing is certain: the stage was set for exceptional college football, and the fireworks did not disappoint.
