Tim Bezbatchenko, president of Black Knight FC, has clarified that the organization does not consider its network of clubs, which includes Bournemouth, Hibs, Lorient, and Auckland, as mere feeder clubs for the Premier League side. This statement comes amid ongoing discussions about player transfers within their multi-club system. Bezbatchenko emphasized that while there is an expectation for players to ascend through the ranks, the approach is not as straightforward as treating the clubs as developmental teams for Bournemouth.
Since Black Knight's investment in Hibs in February 2024, which saw the group acquire a 25 percent stake, the only player to have transferred directly between Bournemouth and Hibs is Owen Bevan, whose move was hindered by injury. Bezbatchenko noted that the strategy is to ensure that any intra-group transfer benefits all parties involved, especially Hibs, which is striving to build a competitive team for its community and fan base.
Bezbatchenko, speaking on The Athletic FC Podcast, stated, "We don't look at the clubs as feeder clubs. I think within the multi-club ownership groups, there are different groups that do consider their clubs feeder clubs. It doesn't mean that we're not looking for the players to move up the pyramid, and I think Bill Foley has been clear about that. But we have to respect their own identity and what they're trying to achieve, and that's really important, especially right now at a club like Lorient, where they're trying to get promoted."
He pointed out that recent transactions, such as those involving Dango Ouattara and Junior Kroupi, have been beneficial for the clubs involved. For instance, Kroupi has remained at Lorient to help them pursue their promotion goals, illustrating Black Knight's commitment to supporting each club's objectives rather than merely funneling talent to Bournemouth.
Bezbatchenko elaborated on the importance of creating a mutually beneficial environment for players within the network. He remarked, "Ultimately, players want to realize their potential. They want to move up the ladder. So whether or not that's within Black Knight or not, we're never going to stand in a player's way as long as we can find a mutually beneficial situation." This approach reflects a broader philosophy of controlling supply and mitigating risks associated with player acquisitions.
One of the challenges of acquiring players, Bezbatchenko explained, is the uncertainty surrounding how a player will fit into a new team. He stated, "You can do as much scouting, as much recruiting, you can have as many interviews as you want, but until that player is in the locker room and out on the training pitch with the other players, you don't know how he's going to fit in with the group." However, having a network allows for more direct observation and assessment of players, which can lead to better integration and chemistry on the field.
Looking ahead, Black Knight FC is currently in what Bezbatchenko calls "phase one" of a five-year strategic plan. This phase involves assessing current operations and laying the groundwork for future growth. Key objectives include potentially acquiring another club, enhancing inter-club relationships, and increasing player movement across the network.
Bezbatchenko expressed optimism about the future, stating, "I think right now we're in phase one. We're assessing and we're in creation mode, where we're coming up with a three to five-year strategy. We're in growth mode, so I think we're still looking at potentially acquiring another club." He also mentioned a recent strategic partnership with Kyoto Sanga in Japan's J-League and discussions with MLS teams about potential collaborations.
Another significant goal for Black Knight FC is to have their clubs compete in European tournaments and challenge for trophies. Bezbatchenko believes that with Hibs currently positioned to secure European football next season, the vision of success is within reach. He articulated the ambition clearly: "We want trophies. Who doesn't? Some of the best experiences I've had in my career are lifting trophies with people that you work with and that you care about. And I don't think it should be any different for our clubs."
Critics, including former Scotland manager Gordon Strachan, have raised concerns about the potential conflicts of interest stemming from the partnership between Hibs and Bournemouth. In November 2024, Strachan suggested that the arrangement could lead to complications, stating, "If you want complete control of the club, buy it. Don't give me 25% then start to tell us what we're doing because there are two different things going on here." He highlighted the need for Hibs to prioritize their own objectives rather than become overly reliant on Bournemouth for player development.
Despite these criticisms, Bezbatchenko remains focused on the long-term vision for Black Knight FC and its clubs. He is committed to fostering an environment where each club retains its identity while also benefiting from the collective strength of the network. As the multi-club model evolves, the emphasis on mutual respect and shared goals will be crucial in navigating the complexities of player transfers and club dynamics.
In summary, Black Knight FC is working to establish a unique approach to multi-club ownership that respects the individual aspirations of each club within its network. By prioritizing mutually beneficial arrangements and fostering strong relationships among clubs, Bezbatchenko aims to create a sustainable model that not only enhances player development but also leads to success on the field.
