The tension between two beloved stars, Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar, recently became the focal point of speculation following Gellar's awkward reaction to questions about Hewitt during the red carpet premiere of her new show, Dexter: Original Sin.
The uncomfortable moment occurred on December 12, 2023, when Gellar was asked if her former co-star would be involved in the forthcoming sequel to their iconic film, I Know What You Did Last Summer. Gellar’s response, which involved tightening her lips and stating, "I have nothing to do with [that]," implied discomfort as she quickly moved on, leaving the audience questioning the status of their relationship.
Fans reacted swiftly across social media, dissecting Gellar’s response. One user noted, "Look at her face!! She hates her so much!" Many perceived Gellar’s expression and delivery as icy, prompting widespread speculation about the possibility of unresolved tension between the two actresses. Given their history of collaboration, the public's curiosity surged once again.
Adding fuel to the fire, Gellar has been criticized for her 'shady' response, especially considering her continuing ties to the production through her husband, Freddie Prinze Jr., who also starred in the original film. Gellar’s social media activity, including her recent praise of the newly appointed director for the sequel, highlighted her professional commitment, yet failed to clarify her feelings about Hewitt.
This moment is not the first time rumors have circulated about their relationship. Back in 2014, Gellar made headlines when she cynically remarked on Australian television, "I know what your boobs did last summer," referencing the ample cleavage featured prominently by Hewitt's character in the original movie. Such comments have often led fans to wonder about the nature of their friendship.
Some viewers dismissed the speculation, arguing Gellar simply reacted defensively to what seemed like a rude question by the interviewer about Hewitt's role, especially since the focus was meant to be on her new project, Dexter: Original Sin. "Why would a reporter ask her about something she has no part in?" questioned another social media user, highlighting the awkwardness of the situation.
Despite opposing views from fans, some users fervently insist on the existence of tension. "Omg,that face she made was so sassy," mocked one observer, who might not have been alone. Queries ranging from "Was there beef between them?" to stranger insights like, "You can tell by the way Sarah reacted about Jennifer. Something happened," emerged, echoing the public's desire to understand the intricacies of their relationship.
Jennifer Love Hewitt, whose own career path has seen her face age-shaming and online scrutiny, recently voiced her thoughts on the negative perceptions women endure, stating, "Age is age. I think women really come to this acceptance of themselves and comfortability in their 40s… and it’s hurtful sometimes when people reject you as you are verbally on Instagram or the internet." Such sentiments resonate deeply with fans, many of whom admire her evolution over the years.
The upcoming sequel to I Know What You Did Last Summer, scheduled for release on July 18, 2025, continues to provoke enthusiasm among audiences, with hopes for the original stars to reprise their iconic roles. Despite this, it remains unclear where Gellar stands as her character, who was killed off during the first movie, will not return. The film aims to blend familiar faces with new talent, ensuring the franchise's legacy continues.
While insights suggest Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. are negotiating their return, Gellar's hasty retreat from the interview raises questions around whether she spoke out of turn previously about the film’s developments, potentially aggravation her public persona. "Gellar is reluctant to divulge too much [about the movie] because... she got in trouble already by posting about the movie before it was even announced," one source explained.
Overall, the intriguing public reactions following Gellar's response serve to amplify the longstanding interest surrounding her relationship with Jennifer Love Hewitt. With persistent rumors alongside moments of irony seeping through from their past, fans are left intrigued by what truly lies beneath the surface of their apparent tension.
Despite various interpretations of their encounter, the unresolved rumors of animosity between Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar continue to captivate audiences. Whether their relationship evolves or remains the subject of speculation is left for future interviews and personal revelations.
