Newcastle United's hopes for the upcoming Carabao Cup final against Liverpool have taken a significant hit following the red card handed to Anthony Gordon during their recent FA Cup clash against Brighton. The Magpies forward was dismissed after pushing Brighton defender Jan Paul van Hecke, leading to widespread discussions about the incident and its repercussions.
The controversial moment occurred during the second half of the FA Cup fifth-round match at St. James' Park when the score was tied at 1-1. Frustration appeared to be the underlying cause as Gordon felt hard done by after being denied a penalty moments earlier. He aggressively pushed Van Hecke, prompting referee Anthony Taylor to show him a straight red card, and VAR confirmed the decision, leading to Gordon facing a three-game suspension for violent conduct.
Magpies manager Eddie Howe expressed his disappointment over the incident, stating, "Of course. If we analyse the incident and feel there's grounds for [an appeal], we will do without hesitation." He noted he had yet to review the footage but insisted Gordon's actions did not typically reflect his character. Howe reaffirmed his trust in Gordon's general demeanor, highlighting the forward's competitive spirit without malice.
Football pundit Paul Robinson, covering the match for BBC Radio 5 Live, criticized Gordon's actions: "Petulance, that's all it was. Gordon knows he cannot get there, and he has run to Van Hecke with two hands. It looked like frustration to me. It was stupid from him." The analysis has been mirrored by various commentators, reitering the necessity for players to maintain composure during high-stakes matches.
This ban is particularly crushing for Newcastle as it means they will enter the Carabao Cup final without one of their key players. Gordon, who has made significant contributions this season with nine goals and six assists, is now set to miss the final on March 16—his second consecutive absence from the cup final, having missed the 2023 final due to being cup-tied after playing for Everton.
Reflecting on his missed opportunity last year, Gordon revealed his regrets about participating in what he deemed "a stupid cup game" just before joining Newcastle, citing injury concerns during his previous appearance. "I was devastated last time... I just thought, 'why did I play in this game?'" he lamented. Gordon had expressed enthusiasm for finally making his mark at Wembley, highlighting the importance of the match to him personally.
The situation worsened for Newcastle as Alexander Isak, their top goal scorer, was replaced by Callum Wilson after limping off during the same FA Cup clash. Isak had previously scored from the penalty spot to put Newcastle ahead, but his exit raised concerns about his fitness heading toward the final against Liverpool.
Eddie Howe addressed Isak's condition, stating, "If Anthony is missing the game then, of course, that's going to be a big blow to us. But we rely on the strength of our squad, and there’s talent waiting to step up where needed.”
This red card incident marks not just another misfortune for Newcastle but recalls past challenges the club has faced during major fixtures. The shadow of missing key players during decisive matches looms large, especially for fans who vividly recall the 2023 final where they played without goalkeeper Nick Pope, who was also suspended.
While the penalty area confrontation between Gordon and Van Hecke drew its share of controversy, Newcastle's lack of scoring momentum following their strong season's start must also be considered. The red card not only impacted the game at hand but could well alter their capacity to challenge Liverpool effectively.
Gordon had pivotal roles earlier, especially during the semi-finals against Arsenal, scoring important goals contributing to Newcastle's advancement. This unfortunate red card now raises questions about squad resilience as they prepare for the final.
With the Carabao Cup final on the horizon, Newcastle will need to rally without Gordon. His teammates, including Jacob Murphy, may have to step up to fill the void left by his absence. The stakes are undeniably high, and anticipation builds as the team gears up to face their childhood club, Liverpool, seeking silverware amid turbulent times.
Howe’s focus now shifts to maintaining morale and tactical preparation. He was clear about the emotional challenges facing his squad following the loss and red card, stating, "It will be flat. You have to let the emotions of the game run out, and then we have to start work." Finding motivation will be pivotal as Newcastle readies for another chance at cup glory.