In a thrilling return to the screen, the sequel to the 2018 hit film A Simple Favor, titled Another Simple Favor, is now available for streaming on Amazon Prime Video. Released on May 1, 2025, at 3 AM Eastern Time, the film brings back fan-favorite characters in a plot filled with twists, turns, and a touch of dark humor.
The story picks up with Stephanie Smothers (played by Anna Kendrick), who has become a minor celebrity and author after helping to put her former friend, the double murderer Emily Nelson (played by Blake Lively), behind bars. Five years later, Emily has secured an early release from prison thanks to her wealthy fiancé’s legal team and is eager to reconnect with Stephanie. In a surprising twist, Emily invites Stephanie to be her maid of honor at her wedding on the picturesque island of Capri, Italy.
However, this seemingly innocent request is layered with tension, as Stephanie is unsure of Emily's true intentions. The film’s director, Paul Feig, emphasizes the stark contrast between Lively's real-life persona and her character, stating, "Blake just embodies Emily in a way that's hilarious because Blake in real life is nothing like Emily. Blake is very sweet, this, like, wonderful mother, and just this tiger comes out when she gets into Emily." Feig’s praise for Lively highlights her ability to seamlessly transition into the complex character of Emily, who is both charming and menacing.
As the wedding approaches, the plot thickens. Stephanie arrives in Capri, where she encounters a cast of colorful characters, including Emily's new fiancé, Dante Versano, whose connections to the Mafia add an element of danger. Notably, Emily's estranged mother and her eccentric aunt, portrayed by Elizabeth Perkins and Allison Janney, respectively, add to the drama. The film quickly escalates when Emily’s ex-husband, Sean, is found dead under mysterious circumstances, setting off a chain of events that leads to more murders and betrayals.
In addition to its thrilling plot, Another Simple Favor does not shy away from exploring darker themes. The film is rife with sexual content, violence, and substance abuse, making it a stark contrast to the comedic undertones of the original. Critics have noted that while the film maintains an engaging narrative, it also dives into explicit territory that may not be suitable for all audiences. The review from Plugged In points out that the film is “pervaded with sexual content” and includes graphic violence, which may deter some viewers.
Despite these concerns, the chemistry between Lively and Kendrick remains a highlight. Their dynamic is described as "through the roof" by Feig, who believes that no other actresses could portray these roles as effectively as they do. Lively herself has expressed her enjoyment in playing Emily, calling her "probably my favorite character I've ever been fortunate enough to play." This enthusiasm resonates throughout the film, making it a compelling watch for fans of the original.
As Stephanie navigates the treacherous waters of friendship and betrayal, she finds herself drawn into a web of deceit that challenges her detective skills. The film’s narrative is filled with unexpected twists, particularly as it reveals Emily's true motives. The tension escalates when Emily's past as a triplet comes to light, unveiling a shocking family history that intertwines with the present events of the wedding.
In a climactic turn of events, Emily's sister Charity, who was thought to be dead, resurfaces and plays a pivotal role in the unfolding chaos. After a series of betrayals, including a deadly confrontation involving Dante, the film reaches a fever pitch as Stephanie must unravel the mystery before it’s too late.
The film's ending leaves viewers on the edge of their seats, with a cliffhanger that hints at further complications in Emily's life. As Portia, Dante's mother, ominously tells Emily, "I know what you did, Hope," it’s clear that the story is far from over. This sets the stage for a potential sequel, keeping audiences eager for more.
Amid the excitement of the film’s release, Blake Lively is also navigating a personal legal battle. She has accused director Justin Baldoni of sexual harassment during the filming of their 2024 movie, It Ends with Us. This controversy adds a layer of complexity to her public persona, but Feig's unwavering support highlights the strong bond they share as collaborators.
With its mix of humor, suspense, and drama, Another Simple Favor promises to captivate audiences while exploring the darker sides of friendship and betrayal. As viewers dive into this twisted tale, they are reminded of the complexities of human relationships and the lengths to which people will go to protect those they love.
For those interested in catching up on the original, A Simple Favor is available for rent or purchase on Prime Video, ensuring that fans can enjoy the full story leading up to the sequel. With its engaging plot and strong performances, Another Simple Favor is a must-watch for fans of the genre.
