In a year filled with unexpected sequels, the release of Another Simple Favor has sparked a notable divide among critics and audiences. Directed by Paul Feig, this sequel to the 2018 film A Simple Favor revisits the tumultuous relationship between Stephanie Smothers and Emily Nelson, played by Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively, respectively. The film picks up several years after the events of the first, with Stephanie reuniting with Emily for her extravagant wedding in Capri, Italy.
Despite its lavish setting and star-studded cast, which includes Allison Janney, Michele Morrone, and Henry Golding, the film's reception has been mixed. According to Rotten Tomatoes, Another Simple Favor currently holds a Certified Fresh rating of 70% on the Tomatometer, based on 80 critic reviews. In stark contrast, the audience score sits at a disappointing 40%, reflecting a significant divide between critical and viewer reception.
Critics have generally praised the film's entertainment value, though many feel it lacks the clever character development that made the original a sleeper hit. Mae Abdulbaki of ScreenRant awarded the sequel 6 out of 10 stars, noting that while it is enjoyable, "some of that allure is gone in the sequel." This sentiment echoes the broader critical perspective that, while the film is fun, it falls short of its predecessor's charm.
The plot of Another Simple Favor unfolds as Stephanie, now a true-crime influencer, is pulled back into Emily's chaotic world when Emily, who was previously incarcerated, demands her presence as maid of honor at her wedding. The film's narrative is filled with twists, including a murder that places Stephanie as a suspect, leading her to navigate the treacherous waters of Emily's life once more.
Critics have pointed out that while the film leans heavily into comedy and convoluted plotting, it sacrifices the depth of character exploration that defined the first film. In the sequel, Stephanie's role feels diminished, and the relationship dynamics between the two leads, once rich with tension, have become more predictable. As one critic noted, the film is "more conventional than its predecessor and considerably more predictable."
Audience reactions have been mixed, with some viewers expressing disappointment over Lively's performance and the film's overall direction. One review lamented, "very disappointing that we are still seeing Blake Lively on screen after what she has done," referencing the controversies surrounding the actress in recent months. This backlash may have influenced the film's low audience score, as several reviews criticized Lively's portrayal of Emily as lacking the spark that initially captivated audiences.
On the other hand, the film's vibrant setting in Capri and its glamorous aesthetic have been highlighted as standout features. Critics have noted that the costume design, once again helmed by Renée Ehrlich Kalfus, elevates the film's visual appeal, with Lively's character sporting increasingly extravagant outfits that add to the film's allure.
Despite the mixed reviews, Another Simple Favor remains a highly anticipated sequel, and its performance on streaming platforms will be closely monitored. The film was released on Prime Video on May 1, 2025, and its long-term viewership numbers will be a key indicator of its success or failure in the current entertainment landscape.
In summary, Another Simple Favor offers a blend of comedy, murder, and twists, but it struggles to recapture the magic of its predecessor. While critics have given it a generally positive review, audience reactions suggest a disconnect that may impact its longevity in the streaming world. As viewers dive into this sequel, they will find a film that, while entertaining, may leave them longing for the cleverness and unpredictability of the original.
