Amy Schumer's new comedy film Kinda Pregnant, which premiered on Netflix on February 5, 2025, has faced substantial criticism since its debut. Following its release, the film, which stars Schumer as Lainy—a middle-school teacher who fakes her own pregnancy—has garnered only 22% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics have not been kind, with some branding the film as 'jaw-droppingly unfunny'.
The storyline revolves around Lainy, who feels overshadowed by her best friend Kate's pregnancy. Played by Jillian Bell, Kate has always been the more hesitant one about motherhood, contrasting with Lainy's lifelong dream of becoming a mother. This jealousy prompts Lainy to don a fake baby bump pillow, leading to comedic, albeit cringe-worthy, scenarios.
While Schumer's humor has often landed with audiences, Kinda Pregnant seems to miss the mark. Many critics feel the film flounders under its own weight, with one review stating, 'Kinda Pregnant prefers to stay on the surface. That shallow nature puts more pressure on the comedy, which is challenging because Kinda Pregnant is not exceptionally funny either.' Such sentiments echo across multiple analyses of the movie, indicating it has not successfully captured the charm or depth fans expected from the comedian.
This situation is not entirely new for Schumer; as her earlier works like Trainwreck and her show Inside Amy Schumer marked significant cultural moments. Critics contend, though, her recent endeavors have seemingly failed to stimulate similar excitement. Another critic lamented, 'For thousands of years it’s been believed laughter is the best medicine. Unfortunately, it appears the laughs from Kinda Pregnant have been recalled.'
Regarding the performances, Amy Schumer, who co-wrote the film, delivers her typical blend of crude humor and candor but lacks the spark seen previously. Will Forte, playing Lainy’s romantic interest Josh, and Bell received some praises for their performances. Schumer herself expressed hopes for viewers to walk away with 'a crush on Will Forte,' indicating her affection for his portrayal.
Despite the challenges faced, the chemistry between Schumer and Bell shines through. During press interactions, both emphasized how easy it was for them to connect. 'It was just like we had a shorthand. It was like, we don't have to know,' Schumer described their first meeting after the Emmy's, highlighting their immediate rapport. The nostalgic bond created between their characters serves as the emotional backbone of the film, even if the execution feels lacking.
The directing seat for Kinda Pregnant was filled by Tyler Spindel, known for other Netflix films including The Wrong Missy. There is also significant industry backing from Adam Sandler's production company, Happy Madison. Schumer quipped during interviews about wanting to start her own branch titled 'Ashley Madison,' highlighting the film's raunchy undertones.
Unfortunately, critics suggest the film suffers from overreliance on crude humor without substantial payoff, undercutting the potential for insightful comedy. A review mentioned, 'What texture exists gets steamrolled by the loud and extreme,' pointing to the imbalance of the film’s energy and execution.
With supporting performances from Damon Wayans Jr., Brianne Howey, and Urzila Carlson, the film is filled with comedic talent, but the opportunities to showcase their abilities are missed. One critic succinctly noted, 'An absolutely unfunny 'comedy'... gets wasted on the capable cast,' reflecting disappointment at the missed comedic beats.
While Schumer has not lost her sharp comedic touch altogether, Kinda Pregnant offers insights on the struggles of creativity and humor consistency. The film may serve as a reminder for her to reconnect with her comedic roots, challenging her to reclaim the cultural spotlight she once held.
Fans of Schumer, who have witnessed her rise and evolution, will likely hope Kinda Pregnant is merely the first film of many more to come, leading to new collaborations and growth within her career, celebrating friendship and sisterhood, albeit with mixed results this time around.