The premiere of Season 2 of the beloved series 1923 on February 23, 2024, opened with a moving tribute to actor Cole Brings Plenty, best known for his role as Pete Plenty Clouds. The initial moments saw Cole's image framed by the show's iconic aesthetic, complete with the somber words 'in memoriam.' This solemn remembrance served to honor the memory of Brings Plenty, who tragically lost his life at just 27 years of age.
Cole was found deceased on April 5, 2024, after being reported missing for several days. Authorities discovered his body near Lawrence, Kansas, following investigations sparked by his abandoned vehicle. The shocking circumstances surrounding his disappearance were compounded by earlier reports of his involvement in alleged domestic violence incidents. No foul play has been indicated, as confirmed by local police.
Strikingly, his family expressed deep sorrow through social media, highlighting the struggle they faced during this heart-wrenching period. Joe Brings Plenty, Cole's father, shared on Instagram, "I am deeply saddened to confirm my son, Cole, has been found and is no longer with us. We want to express our heartfelt gratitude to everyone for the prayers and positive thoughts you sent for Cole." He continued with, "During this incredibly difficult time, we ask for privacy as we process our grief and figure out how we move forward." Such heartfelt words reflected the family's loss and emotional turmoil.
The grief felt by the community was palpable, with colleagues from Yellowstone and others within the industry voicing their condolences. Artist Mark Maggiori poignantly stated, "I loved [Cole]. May hisjourney to the other world be a good one. We will visit him later on... much love." This sentiment reveals the collective heartache felt by friends and co-workers who admired him.
Mo Brings Plenty, Cole's uncle and fellow Yellowstone actor, played an instrumental role during the tumultuous times, having shared missing person flyers on social media when Cole first disappeared. His anguish mirrored the community's concern over the situation and the feeling of urgency to find him. The police's search efforts were hampered by the unfortunate circumstance surrounding Cole's case, and police chief Rich Lockhart duly noted, "I learned through this series of events our police department must work harder to increase trust with our Native American community members." His acknowledgment of the inadequacies faced by the Lawrence Police Department speaks to broader systemic challenges within law enforcement and how it impacts relationships with minority communities.
Following Cole’s death, many within the 1923 cast and crew felt his absence deeply. Aminah Nieves, who portrayed Teonna, emotionally recalled, "Coco was definitely there in spirit... the whole season, he was always there." Such reflections shed light on how Cole's legacy will continue to resonate within the series and among those who worked closely with him.
The creators of 1923 decided to recast the role of Pete for the new season, now portrayed by Jeremy Guana. Regardless of this change, the impact of Brings Plenty's performance and presence would not easily fade. The cast has pledged to honor his memory throughout the season, with Nieves stating, "I’m so happy to return for season two, especially able to finish out the chapter with Teonna and then honor our brother Coco." This demonstrates the kind of camaraderie and respect valued within the show.
The first moments of Season 2, infused with nostalgia and melancholy, serve as more than just visual tribute. They remind audiences of the fragility of life and the bonds formed between actors, as well as the importance of community support during dark times. The overwhelming messages of love and respect for Cole show the indelible marks he left during his short life.
Yet the story does not end with his death; instead, it serves as a catalyst for reflection and change. The family, community, and police alike are now faced with the larger question of engagement with Native American communities, particularly around matters of safety and trust. For many, this moment will help push forward discussions about community vigilance and recognition of cultural nuances.
With the new episodes available for streaming on Paramount+, 1923 promises to continue exploring complex narratives woven with human experiences. Norms exceed beyond scripted lines and intimate scenes; they involve resilience, remembrance, and the acknowledgment of the past.
Indeed, Cole Brings Plenty's legacy will resonate as Season 2 progresses, not only among his friends on the show but also within the hearts of viewers who will always carry his memory forward with love and respect.